Date
Venue
City
State
Add
Sources
Set 1
Set 2
Set 3
Comment
WYWH/Animals rough mixes, Abbey Road/Britannia Row
London
England
Have A Cigar
The Machine Song
Shine On You Crazy Diamond intro
Shine On You Crazy Diamond
Dogs part 1
Dogs part 2
Sheep
Pigs (Three Different Ones)
"Let There Beeb More Light"
Various
England
Disc 1
1967-05-14 - Pow R Toc H [Look Of The Week, BBC-TV, Lime Grove Studios, London]
1967-05-14 - Hans Keller [Look Of The Week, BBC-TV, Lime Grove Studios, London]
1967-05-14 - Astronomy Domine [Look Of The Week, BBC-TV, Lime Grove Studios, London]
1967-05-14 - Syd Barrett & Roger Waters interview with Hans Keller [Look Of The Week, BBC-TV, Lime Grove Studios, London]
1967-09-25 - The Gnome [Top Gear, Playhouse Theatre, London]
1967-09-25 - Matilda Mother [Top Gear, Playhouse Theatre, London]
1967-09-25 - The Scarecrow [Top Gear, Playhouse Theatre, London]
1967-09-25 - Flaming [Top Gear, Playhouse Theatre, London]
1967-09-25 - Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun [Top Gear, Playhouse Theatre, London]
1967-09-25 - Reaction In G [Top Gear, Playhouse Theatre, London]
1967-12-12 - Green Onions [Tomorrow's World, BBC-TV, Stanhope Gardens, London]
1967-12-12 - Instrumental [Tomorrow's World, BBC-TV, Stanhope Gardens, London]
1967-12-20 - John Peel [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1967-12-20 - Vegetable Man [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1967-12-20 - Tommy Vance and John Peel [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1967-12-20 - Scream Thy Last Scream [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1967-12-20 - Jugband Blues [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1967-12-20 - Pow R Toc H [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1967-12-20 - John Peel [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1968-03-26 - Untitled [Late Night Lineup - Sound of Change, BBC-TV, Lime Grove Studios, London]
1968-03-28 - Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun [All My Loving, BBC-TV, Abbey Mills Pumping Station, London]
1968-05-25 - Roger Waters interview ['The Story Of Pop' No. 26, BBC Radio]
1968-06-25 - John Peel [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1968-06-25 - Careful With That Axe, Eugene [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1968-06-25 - John Peel [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1968-06-25 - A Saucerful Of Secrets [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1968-06-25 - John Peel [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1968-06-25 - Let There Be More Light [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1968-06-25 - John Peel [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1968-06-25 - Julia Dream [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1968-06-25 - John Peel [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1968-06-25 - John Peel [Top Gear, Piccadilly Studios, London]
1967-07-27 - See Emily Play [Top Of The Pops, BBC-TV, Lime Grove Studios, London]
Disc 2
1968-12-02 - John Peel [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1968-12-02 - Point Me At The Sky [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1968-12-02 - John Peel [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1968-12-02 - The Narrow Way Part 1 [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1968-12-02 - John Peel [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1968-12-02 - The Embryo [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1968-12-02 - John Peel [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1968-12-02 - Interstellar Overdrive [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1968-12-02 - John Peel [Top Gear, Maida Vale Studios, London]
1969-05-12 - Grantchester Meadows [Nite Ride, Paris Cinema, London]
1969-05-12 - Cymbaline [Nite Ride, Paris Cinema, London]
1969-05-12 - Green Is The Colour [Nite Ride, Paris Cinema, London]
1969-05-12 - Careful With That Axe, Eugene [Nite Ride, Paris Cinema, London]
1969-05-12 - Narrow Way Part 3 [Nite Ride, Paris Cinema, London]
1969-07-20 - Moonhead [Omnibus - So What If It's Just Green Cheese, BBC-TV, TV Centre, London]
1970-02-24 - Syd Barrett - Terrapin [Peel Sessions, BBC Radio, London]
1970-02-24 - Syd Barrett - Gigolo Aunt [Peel Sessions, BBC Radio, London]
1970-02-24 - Syd Barrett - Baby Lemonade [Peel Sessions, BBC Radio, London]
1970-02-24 - Syd Barrett - Effervescing Elephant [Peel Sessions, BBC Radio, London]
1970-02-24 - Syd Barrett - Two Of A Kind [Peel Sessions, BBC Radio, London]
1968-12-17 - Cirrus Minor (Laying Down The Tracks) [Science Session - Let's Make Pop, BBC-TV, EMI Studios, London]
Disc 3
1970-07-16 - John Peel [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1970-07-16 - The Embryo [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1970-07-16 - John Peel [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1970-07-16 - Fat Old Sun [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1970-07-16 - John Peel [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1970-07-16 - Green Is The Colour + Careful With That Axe, Eugene [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1970-07-16 - John Peel [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1970-07-16 - If [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1970-07-16 - John Peel [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1970-07-16 - Atom Heart Mother [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
Disc 4
1971-03-01 - Bob Harris [Sounds Of The 70s, BBC Radio, London]
1971-03-01 - Syd Barrett - Baby Lemonade [Sounds Of The 70s, BBC Radio, London]
1971-03-01 - Bob Harris [Sounds Of The 70s, BBC Radio, London]
1971-03-01 - Syd Barrett - Dominoes [Sounds Of The 70s, BBC Radio, London]
1971-03-01 - Bob Harris [Sounds Of The 70s, BBC Radio, London]
1971-03-01 - Syd Barrett - Love Song [Sounds Of The 70s, BBC Radio, London]
1971-09-30 - John Peel [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1971-09-30 - Fat Old Sun [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1971-09-30 - John Peel [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1971-09-30 - One Of These Days [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1971-09-30 - John Peel [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1971-09-30 - The Embryo [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1971-09-30 - John Peel [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1971-09-30 - Echoes [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
1971-09-30 - Blues [Peel Sessions, Paris Theatre, London]
Maxwell Edison Records bootleg
Let There Beeb More Light
The BBC Recordings of Syd Barrett & The Pink Floyd, 1967-74
Collected And Incomplete
Saarlandehalle
Saarbrucken
West Germany
Track list:
1 - Side A (Librest Spacement Monitor & The Embryo)
2 - Side B (Fat Old Sun, Pink Blues*, Atom Heart Mother Reprise*)
3 - Side C (Green is The Colour & A Saucerful of Secrets)
4 - Side D (Atom Heart Mother)
Barrett's Revenge
Compilation
Compilation
Vegetable Man
Pow R. Toc H.
Scream Your Last Scream
Jugband Blues
Julia Dream
Let There Be More Light
Cymbaline
Saucerful Of Secrets
Careful With That Axe, Eugene
Cymbaline
Embryo
Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun
Saucerful Of Secrets
A1 to A4 were recorded in 1967 with Syd Barrett & A5 and A6 were recorded in 1969 with Dave Gilmour.
Side B was recorded live in Amsterdam in 1969.
Side C and D are the best parts of Floyds continental tours in 1970 & 1971.
The Midas Touch
Unknown
Unknown
Point Me At The Sky
Crumbling Land
Rain In The Country
Interstellar Overdrive
Astronomy Domine
The Embryo
Fingals Cave
'POINT ME AT THE SKY' IS THE OFFICIAL RELEASE. OTHER STUDIO TRACKS ARE ZABRISKIE POINT OUTTAKES. 'INTERSTELLAR OVERDRIVE' IS FROM 'ROME GOES POP' TV SHOW 05-05-1968. OTHERS UNKNOWN (SAID TO BE CHICAGO '71).
The Great Lost Pink Floyd Album
Unknown
Unknown
Massed Gadgets Of Hercules
Point Me To The Sky
Let There Be More Light
Grantchester Meadows
Green Is The Colour
Careful With That Axe, Eugene
Baby Blue Shuffle In D Major
Interstellar Overdrive
The Narrow Way
Apple And Oranges
Pow R Toc H
https://www.discogs.com/Pink-Floyd-The-Great-Lost-Pink-Floyd-Album/release/4931666
A1, A3: Top Gear 25.06.1968
A2, B2-B4: Top Gear 14.01.1969
A4-B1: Top Gear 12.05.1969
B6: Top Gear 31.12.1967
1972-1975 - 8mm Compilation
Other
Other
1972-09-22 - Hollywood Bowl, Los Angeles, California, US:
Breathe
Money
Us & Them
Eclipse
One Of These Days
Careful With That Axe, Eugene
Echoes
A Saucerful Of Secrets
1975-04-27 - Sports Arena, Los Angeles, California, US
Have A Cigar
Shine On You Crazy Diamond
Breathe
On The Run
Money
Echoes
1977-02-01 - Stadthalle, Vienna, Austria
Sheep
Dogs
Pigs (Three Different Ones)
Shine On You Crazy Diamond
Have A Cigar
Shine On You Crazy Diamond
Money
Us And Them
1977-05-07 - Stadium, Anaheim, California, US
Sheep
Pigs (Three Different Ones)
1977-03-01 - Olympiahalle, Munich, Germany
Sheep
Pigs On The Wing 1
Dogs
Pigs (Three Different Ones)
Shine On You Crazy Diamond
Welcome To The Machine
Have A Cigar
Shine On You Crazy Diamond
Money
BBC Broadcasts (1967-1971)
Compilation
UK
UFO Club London Jan. 27 1967 BBC TV "Special Scene"
Interstellar Overdrive
Matilda Mother
BBC Television Centre London May 14 1967 "Look Of The Week"
Pow R Toc H
Astronomy Domine
CBC Radio London July 1967
Intersellar Overdrive W/ Interview
Cosmopolitan Ball Room Carlisle U.K. July 23 1967
Reaction In G
Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun
Playhouse Theatre London Sept. 25 1967 "Top Gear"
Flaming
Apples And Oranges
Scarecrow
The Gnome
Matilda Mother
Maida Vale Studios London Dec. 20 1967 "Top Gear"
Vegetable Man
Scream Thy Last Scream
Pow R Toc H
Jugband Blues
Piccadilly Studio 1 London June 25 1968 "Top Gear"
Murderistic Women (aka Careful With That Axe Eugene)
The Massed Gadgets Of Hercules (aka A Saucerful Of Secrets)
Bedrock Records
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 1
Compilation
Compilation
CD1
1 - Lucy Leave (uncredited)
2 - I'm a King Bee (written by Moore recorded by Slim Harpo)
Recorded : London, Thompson Recording Studios, May 15, 1965
Primary source : EMIdisc acetate
Source for the tree : "A Fish out of Water" RoIO CD & "Outtakes from Outer Space" RoIO CD
These two (unreleased) songs appear on a two-sided 7" acetate discovered early 1988.
Whilst some experts consider this as a fake, Miles reproduces in his book a setlist
including "Lucy Leave" for the gig the band played on October 14, 1966.
3 - Let's Roll Another One (Barrett)
Recorded : London, Thompson Recording Studios, October 31, 1966
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : unkown gen copy from outtake
Instrumental rehearsals for this song that later became "Candy and a Current Bun".
This obscure outtake probably comes from the October 1966 session at Thompson Recording
Studios (where the first studio version of "Interstellar Overdrive" was also recorded, and later used
in the "San Francisco" movie).
4 - Arnold Layne (Barrett) - acetate
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, January 23-25, 1967
Primary source : EMIdisc acetate
Source for the tree : "Anthology II" RoIO CD
Fades in 2 seconds after the actual start, strange edit skipping organ solo.
5 - Arnold Layne (Barrett) - mono
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, January 23-25, 1967
Primary source : "Arnold Layne" single (1st single), released March 11, 1967
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
6 - Arnold Layne (Barrett) - fake stereo
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, January 23-25, 1967
Primary source : "The Best of the Pink Floyd" compilation, released 1970
& "Masters of Rock" compilation, released 1973
Source for the tree : "Works" CD
7 - Candy and a Current Bun (Barrett) - acetate
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, January 23-25, 1967
Primary source : EMIdisc acetate
Source for the tree : "Anthology II" RoIO CD
Alternate lyrics ("please just walk with me" while on the regular single version it's "please
just f*** with me"), different verse structure, no organ and guitar solos.
Some people refer to this version as being "Let's Roll Another One" from October 1966 sessions at
Thompson Recording Studios, but since the instrumental tracks are the same as the regular single
version, this probably comes from the same January 1967 sessions at Sound Techniques Studios.
8 - Candy and a Current Bun (Barrett) - mono
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, January 23-25, 1967
Primary source : "Arnold Layne" single (1st single), released March 11, 1967
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
9 - Interstellar Overdrive (Barrett, Waters, Wright, Mason) - demo
Recorded : ?
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy
This obscure demo is probably a fake. However, it has acquired a certain fame in the
trading circle of Pink Floyd fans. We included it here, in order to let you make your own
opinion. Some say it was recorded on a cheap cassette recorder, by two guys playing
guitar simultaneously, sometime during the 80s. Note that the first riff after the intro is
identical to the bass riff that can be heard on the "Piper at the Gates of Dawn" version,
and that earlier versions of the song (on "San Francisco" soundtrack or "Tonite Let's All
Make Love in London" soundtrack) don't contain this particular riff. This leads to the
conclusion that this "demo" was probably recorded after the release of "The Piper At The
Gates Of Dawn" album.
10 - Interstellar Overdrive (Barrett, Waters, Wright, Mason) - Sound Techniques outtake
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, January 31 - February 1, 1967
Primary source : CBC Canadian Radio broadcast, early 1967
Source for the tree : "Stone Rust" RoIO CD & "Dark Globe" RoIO CD
& "The Sights And Sounds Of Syd Barrett's Pink Floyd" RoIO CD
Extracts from the 3rd studio version of "Interstellar Overdrive" can be heard in the
background, during an interview broadcast in early 1967 by CBC Canadian Radio.
Pink Floyd recorded 4 different studio versions of "Interstellar Overdrive". The first version was
recorded in October 1966 at Thompson Recording Studios, and was later used in the 1968 "San
Francisco" movie. The second version was recorded on January 11, 1967, at Sound Techniques
Studios, and was used in the "Tonite Let's All Make Love in London" movie. The third version was
recorded during the "Arnold Layne" / "Candy and a Current Bun" sessions at Sound Techniques
Studios. Only extracts from this version have surfaced, they can be heard in the background during
the CBC broadcast from early 1967. The fourth version was recorded at Abbey Road in March 1967,
and is the regular version that can be found on "The Piper at the Gates of Dawn" album.
11 - Interstellar Overdrive (Barrett, Waters, Wright, Mason) - Abbey Road outtake
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, March 14-15, 1967
Primary source : BBC broadcast, 1967
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from BBC broadcast
Outtake from "The Piper at the Gates of Dawn" sessions, broadcast by the BBC in 1967.
12 - Interstellar Overdrive (Barrett, Waters, Wright, Mason) - mono single version
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, March 14-15, 1967
Primary source : "Arnold Layne" French EP, released 1967
Source for the tree : "Anthology II" RoIO CD
This version is unique, because it only contains the basic track, without overdubs. It
fades out before the actual end of the song.
13 - Scarecrow (Barrett) - Abbey Road outtake
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, March 19-20, 1967
Primary source : BBC broadcast, 1967
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from BBC broadcast
Outtake from "The Piper at the Gates of Dawn" sessions, broadcast by the BBC in 1967.
All the instruments are heavily undermixed. This is nearly an unplugged version ?.
14 - Scarecrow (Barrett) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, March 19-20, 1967
Primary source : "See Emily Play" single (2nd single), released June 16, 1967
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
15 - Astronomy DominÈ (Barrett) - Abbey Road outtake
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, April 11-12, 1967
Primary source : BBC broadcast, 1967
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from BBC broadcast
Outtake from "The Piper at the Gates of Dawn" sessions, broadcast by the BBC in 1967,
including an interview with Floyd's manager Peter Jenner.
16 - See Emily Play (Barrett) - actetate
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, May 18 & 21, 1967
Primary source : EMI disc acetate
Source for the tree : "Dawn Of The Piper" RoIO CD
This version is very close to the regular one, there are only slight changes in the mix
(vocals are undermixed, organ is more in the front...). Note that the very end is uncut.
17 - See Emily Play (Barrett) - mono
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, May 18 & 21, 1967
Primary source : "See Emily Play" single (2nd single), released June 16, 1967
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
18 - See Emily Play (Barrett) - fake stereo
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, May 18 & 21, 1967
Primary source : "The Best of the Pink Floyd" compilation, released 1970
& "Masters of Rock" compilation, released 1973
Source for the tree : "A CD Full of Secrets" CD
19 - Flaming (Barrett) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 7 & 27, 1967
Primary source : "Flaming" US single (3rd US single), released November 2, 1967.
Source for the tree : "A CD Full of Secrets" CD
"Flaming" was not on the first US release of "The Piper at the Gates of Dawn" album, and
was then released as a single. This version is different from the regular (stereo) mix:
background noises are mixed much louder.
In fact, this version is identical to the version on the mono edition of "The Piper at the Gates of
Dawn" album. Curiously, on the 30th Anniversary Mono Edition CD released in 1997, one chord of
the final chords sequence was edited out.
20 - Sunshine (uncredited)
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 29, 1967
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "Dawn Of The Piper" RoIO CD
This track was probably recorded during the "Piper at the Gates of Dawn" sessions.
Malcom Jones, in his book "The Making of the Madcap Laughs", suggests this is an early version of
"Remember a Day". Some think it's in fact a part of "Matilda Mother", that was recorded the same
day ...
21 - Silas Lane (uncredited)
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1967
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "Vegetable Man, Where Are You" RoIO LP
This outtake was probably recorded during the "Piper at the Gates of Dawn" sessions.
These are the early chords of Barrett's song "Swan Lee (Silas Lang)". Note that the piano
and jazz tunes may be due to a technical error while dubbing the original multitrack
master tape onto cassette. The definitive version of "Swan Lee" was recorded by Barrett
one year later and released on "Opel" in 1988. Some think this outtake comes from a
Barrett solo session.
22 - Scream Thy Last Scream (Barrett) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, August 7-8, 1967
Primary source : EMIdisc acetate
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy
This was intended to be the A-side of Pink Floyd's fourth single (after "Apples and
Oranges" single). But due to Syd's departure from the band, it remained unreleased.
CD2
1 - Scream Thy Last Scream (Barrett) - stereo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, August 7-8, 1967
Primary source : EMIdisc acetate
Source for the tree : "Dawn Of The Piper" RoIO CD
On this version, the instruments and vocals are mainly mono. However, some stereo
effects can be heard, especially on the background noises (high pitched voices).
2 - Vegetable Man (Barrett) - mono
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, September 5-6, 1967
Primary source : EMIdisc acetate
Source for the tree : "Magnesium Proverbs" RoIO CD
This was intended to be the B-side of "Scream Thy Last Scream" single.
3 - Vegetable Man (Barrett) - alternate mono
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, September 5-6, 1967
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy
Alternate mono version, with more laughter at the end, without echo and delay.
4 - Vegetable Man (Barrett) - stereo
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, September 5-6, 1967
Primary source : EMIdisc acetate
Source for the tree : "Dawn Of The Piper" RoIO CD
Stereo version, with background vocals and delays effects mixed louder.
5 - Remember A Day (Wright) - mono short version
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, October 5-6, 1967
Primary source : "Remember A Day" US promo single, released August 19, 1968
Source for the tree : 1st gen copy from "Remember A Day" promo single
This version fades out before the last verse.
6 - Apples and Oranges (Barrett) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, October 30 - November 1, 1967
Primary source : "Apples and Oranges" UK single (3rd UK single), released November 18, 1967
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
7 - Apples and Oranges (Barrett) - stereo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, October 30 - November 1, 1967
Primary source : "The Best of the Pink Floyd" compilation, released 1970
& "Masters of Rock" compilation, released 1973
Source for the tree : "A CD Full of Secrets" CD
Curiously, on "A CD Full of Secrets", the right and left channels were inverted, comparing to the
original stereo version on "The Best of the Pink Floyd" and "Masters of Rock".
8 - Paint Box (Wright) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, October 30 - November 1, 1967
Primary source : "Apples and Oranges" UK single (3rd UK single), released November 18, 1967
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
9 - Paint Box (Wright) - stereo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, October 30 - November 1, 1967
Primary source : "The Best of the Pink Floyd" compilation, released 1970
& "Masters of Rock" compilation, released 1973
Source for the tree : "Relics" CD
Faster ending fade out.
10 - Let There Be More Light (Waters) - mono edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January 17-18, 1968
Primary source : "Remember A Day" US promo single, released August 19, 1968
Source for the tree : 1st gen copy from "Remember A Day" promo single
There's an edit during the intro, the 2nd verse ("Now is the time to be aware...") is
missing, the beginning of the instrumental part after the last verse was cut, and there's
an early fade out.
11 - Corporal Clegg (Waters) - video version
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January 31, 1968
Primary source : Belgian promo video
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from Belgian promo video
This mono version has an alternate ending: the last chorus (just after "His boots were
very clean") and the following instrumental part are alternate takes from the regular
version.
12 - It Would Be So Nice (Wright) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, February 12-13 & March 5-12-21, 1968
Primary source : "It Would Be So Nice" single (4th single), released April 12, 1968
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
Due to the "Evening Standard" mention in the original lyrics, the Floyd was forced to
return in the studio to change it into "Daily Standard". The original "Evening Standard"
version doesn't seem to have surfaced.
13 - It Would Be So Nice (Wright) - promo edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, February 12-13 & March 5-12-21, 1968
Primary source : "It Would Be So Nice" UK promo single, released April 12, 1968
Source for the tree : ?
The central "It would be so nice" chorus is only sung once, and the first lines of the
second verse ("Everybody cares about the weather ... what a waste of time") are edited.
14 - It Would Be So Nice (Wright) - fake stereo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, February 12-13 & March 5-12-21, 1968
Primary source : "The Best of the Pink Floyd" compilation, released 1970
& "Masters of Rock" compilation, released 1973
Source for the tree : "A CD Full of Secrets" CD
Curiously, on "A CD Full of Secrets", the right and left channels were inverted, comparing to the
original fake stereo version on "The Best of the Pink Floyd" and "Masters of Rock".
15 - Julia Dream (Waters) - demo
Recorded : ?
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy
This obscure demo is probably a fake. However, it has acquired a certain fame in the
trading circle of Pink Floyd fans. We included it here, in order to let you make your own
opinion. It has surfaced on the same tape that contains the (fake) demo of "Interstellar
Overdrive" (one can hear the beginning of "Interstellar Overdrive" right after the end of
"Julia Dream"). So, this was probably recorded by the same guys.
16 - Julia Dream (Waters) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, February 12-13 & March 23, 1968
Primary source : "It Would Be So Nice" single (4th single), released April 12, 1968
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
17 - Julia Dream (Waters) - stereo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, February 12-13 & March 23, 1968
Primary source : "Relics" compilation, released May 14, 1971
Source for the tree : "Relics" CD
18 - Point Me at the Sky (Waters, Gilmour) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, November 3-4, 1968
Primary source : "Point Me at the Sky" UK single (5th UK single), released December 17, 1968
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
19 - Point Me at the Sky (Waters, Gilmour) - fake stereo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, November 3-4, 1968
Primary source : "A CD Full of Secrets" promo sampler CD, released 1992
Source for the tree : "A CD Full of Secrets" CD
20 - Careful with that Axe, Eugene (Waters, Wright, Gilmour, Mason) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, November 3-4, 1968
Primary source : "Point Me at the Sky" UK single (5th UK single), released December 17, 1968
Source for the tree : "The Pink Floyd Early Singles" CD
21 - Careful with that Axe, Eugene (Waters, Wright, Gilmour, Mason) - stereo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, November 3-4, 1968
Primary source : "Relics" compilation, released May 14, 1971
Source for the tree : "Relics" CD
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation (studio). 17 Discs.
(Volume 1 (CD1 - CD2): Pink Floyd Rarities 1965 - 1968)
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 2
Compilation
Unknown
CD3
1 - Astronomy Domine (Barrett) - live short version
Recorded : live, Bromley, Technical College, April 26, 1969
& Birmingham, Mother's Club, April 27, 1969
& Manchester, College of Commerce, May 2, 1969
Primary source : "The New Spirit of Capitol" sampler, released 1969?
Source for the tree : "The New Spirit of Capitol" sampler
"Ummagumma" live version with early fade out.
2 - Embryo (Waters)
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, April - June 1969
Primary source : "Picnic - A Breath of Fresh Air" Harvest sampler, released June 1970
Source for the tree : "Works" CD
This version is often considered as a demo. In fact, it was recorded during the
"Ummagumma" studio sessions at Abbey Road, but it was not included on the album,
because the band later decided to organise the studio disc in four parts (one part for
each member). This song first appeared in June 1970 on "Picnic - A Breath of Fresh Air"
Harvest sampler, without the band's agreement. In 1983, this version was included on
"Works" Canadian compilation, this time with the band's agreement.
3 - Biding My Time (Waters)
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, April - June 1969
Primary source : "Relics" compilation, released May 14, 1971
Source for the tree : "Relics" CD
This is the other song that was recorded during the "Ummagumma" studio sessions, but
was not included on the album. This track was part of "The Man & the Journey" concept
suite that the Floyd used to perform in 1969.
Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered together in a Cave and Grooving with a Pict
(Waters)
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, April - June 1969
Primary source : "Ummagumma" album, released October 25, 1969
Source for the tree : "Ummagumma" 1994 remaster CD
Length :
4 - "this is pretty avant-garde isn't it"
During Roger Waters' speech at 04:32, this sentence can be heard on the right channel
(you have to play the song at half speed to hear it properly).
5 - "and the wind cried ... "
There was a strong debate about what Roger says at the very end of the track: "And the
wind cried Mary ? Marion ? Back ? ". Make your own opinion before Dave thanks you ;-)
Note : it is also said that at some point Roger says "Bring Back My Guitar", but we haven't been
able to find this sentence during the song (or nothing that could be clearly identified as this).
6 - Moonhead (uncredited)
Recorded : July 10, 1969
Primary source : BBC TV broadcast, July 20, 1969
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy
This unreleased track was recorded by the band for the BBC TV broadcast during the
night of the first moon landing (July 20, 1969). The show was subtitled "What if it's just
green cheese". Note that the bass line later developed into the central part of "Money".
Atom Heart Mother (Mason, Gilmour, Waters, Wright, Geesin) - announcements
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, 1970
Primary source : "Atom Heart Mother" album, released October 10, 1970
Source for the tree : "Atom Heart Mother" remaster CD
7 - "here's a loud announcement"
This sentence was probably said by Ron Geesin (co-composer of the track) and can be
heard at 17:28.
8 - "silence in the studio"
Another sentence by Ron Geesin. Can be heard at 19:08
9 - Green is the Colour (Waters) - live
10 - Careful with that Axe, Eugene (Waters, Wright, Gilmour, Mason) - live short version
11 - Embryo (Waters) - live short version
12 - Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun (Waters) - live short version
Recorded : live, Hamburg, Muzikhalle, Grosser Saal, February 25, 1971
Primary source : "Hamburger" RoIO LP
Source for the tree : "Pink Floyd In Concerto" Italian single
These 4 tracks come from an Italian single entitled "Pink Floyd In Concerto" that was
released as a bonus with the "Gong" magazine, sometimes in the 70's. This one plays
extracts from a bootleg LP ("Hamburger"). When the powers that be found it was
bootlegged music, they tried to stop the magazine selling, but some copies went through.
The single was later re-released as a bonus with another bootleg LP ("A Special Treat").
Here's what the front cover of the single says: "Supplemento al No 1 anno 4o di 'GONG'
mensile di musica e cultura progressiva. 'PINK FLOYD IN CONCERTO' 16 minuti di musica
live da monaco di baviera".
13 - "Relics" radio advert #1
14 - "Relics" radio advert #2
Recorded : ?
Primary source : radio broadcast
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from radio broadcast
15 - "Meddle" radio advert
Recorded : ?
Primary source : radio broadcast
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from radio broadcast
16 - One of These Days (Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour) - demo #1
Recorded : 1971?
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "Granny Takes A Trip" RoIO CD
Nick Mason's words "One of these days I'm going to cut you into little pieces" are
repeated all through the song. The voice in the background all along the track is the one
of Jimmy Young, an English DJ who was disliked by the band and is the inspiration for
the song. This Jimmy Young speech was also used during live performances in late 1974,
when the band played a tape of this speech (in loop mode, with increasing tempo) before
the song "Raving and Drooling" (early version of "Sheep").
17 - One of These Days (Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour) - demo #2
Recorded : 1971?
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "Granny Takes A Trip" RoIO CD
This second demo is more structured, and Jimmy Young is not talking in the background.
Note that some Floyd experts think these 2 demos could be a fake.
18 - One of These Days (Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour) - mono edit
Recorded : London, Morgan Studios, 1971
Primary source : "One Of These Days" US promo single, released 1971
Source for the tree : "One Of These Days" US promo single
Various short edits all along the song.
19 - Fearless (Gilmour, Waters) - mono edit
Recorded : London, 1971
Primary source : "One Of These Days" US promo single, released 1971
Source for the tree : "One Of These Days" US promo single
There's only one verse, which is mainly the first verse of the original version (until "just
wait a while for the right day"), where the last lines were replaced by those of the second
verse ("and as you rise ... faces in the crowd"). This version also fades out early.
20 - Roger the Hat interview
Recorded : 1972
Primary source : Capital Radio broadcast ("Pink Floyd Story"), December 1976 - January 1977
Source for the tree : unknown gen from Capital Radio broadcast
All though "The Dark Side of the Moon" album, you can hear the voices of people
interviewed by the band. Here, Roger the Hat (who was a roadie for various rock bands)
is interviewed by Roger Waters. On the album, you can hear his voice during "On the
Run" ("Live for today, gone tomorrow, that's me, hahaha") and during "Us And Them"
("Short, sharp shock").
CD4
1 - Breathe (Waters, Gilmour, Wright) - mono
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "The Dark Side Of The Moon" US promo EP, released 1973
Source for the tree : 1st gen copy from "Breathe" promo single
2 - On the Run (Gilmour, Waters) - outtake
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, November 1972
Primary source : "Live At Pompeii" film
Source for the tree : "Live At Pompeii" LaserDisc
Studio outtake with interview segments. You can hear a keyboard jam in the first part
and then a nearly finished mix in the second part.
3 - Time (Mason, Waters, Wright, Gilmour) - demo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "From the Other Side" RoIO CD
Rough mix from "The Dark Side of the Moon" recording sessions. Longer rototom intro.
The instrumental part after "you missed the starting gun" has no guitar solo. It fades out
at the beginning of "Breathe - reprise" (just before the words "Home, home again").
4 - Time (Mason, Waters, Wright, Gilmour) - stereo edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "Us And Them" single, released 1973
Source for the tree : 1st gen copy from "Us And Them" single
Shorter rototom intro, most of the central guitar solo is missing, rototom outro in place of
"Breathe - reprise".
5 - Time (Mason, Waters, Wright, Gilmour) - mono edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "The Dark Side Of The Moon" US promo EP, released 1973
Source for the tree : "The Dark Side Of The Moon" US promo EP
Same as previous edit: shorter rototom intro, most of the central guitar solo is missing,
rototom outro in place of "Breathe - reprise".
6 - Money (Waters) - demo
Recorded : 1971
Primary source : BBC Radio One interview with David Gilmour, broadcast July 28, 1992
Source for the tree : "Pinkie Milkie" RoIO CD
Extract of Roger's early demo of the song. He plays a double tracked acoustic guitar
while singing over the top.
7 - Money (Waters) - stereo edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "Money" single, released May 5, 1973
Source for the tree : "Money" 1993 UK Promo CD
The intro is shorter, the central part of the sax solo is edited, as well as parts 2 & 3 of the
guitar solo (quiet part and theme reprise).
8 - Money (Waters) - "soft" stereo edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "Money" US promo single, released May 1973
Source for the tree : "Money" US promo single
Same as previous edit, plus "shit" edit during the sentence "Don't give me that do goody
good bullshit".
9 - Money (Waters) - "soft" mono edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "Money" US promo single, released May 1973
Source for the tree : "Money" US promo single
Same as previous edit: the intro is shorter, the central part of the sax solo is edited, as
well as parts 2 & 3 of the guitar solo and the word "shit" during the sentence "Don't give
me that do goody good bullshit".
10 - Money (Waters) - alternate "soft" mono edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "The Dark Side Of The Moon" US promo EP, released 1973
Source for the tree : "The Dark Side Of The Moon" US promo EP
Shorter intro, no sax solo, edited guitar solo, plus "shit edit" during the sentence "Don't
give me that do goody good bullshit".
11 - Us And Them (Waters, Wright) - demo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "From the Other Side" RoIO CD
Sax solo is not mixed on and off, no echo on vocals, different piano part at the end.
12 - Us And Them (Waters, Wright) - outtake
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, November 1972
Primary source : "Live At Pompeii" film
Source for the tree : "Live At Pompeii" LaserDisc
Studio outtake with interview segments. The work in progressÖ
Note that in the film (at 04:05), an extract of "Eclipse" is inserted before David Gilmour
says "It's an imagery we'd like to dispelÖ". We have reported this extract at the end of
this disc.
13 - Us And Them (Waters, Wright) - stereo edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "Us And Them" US promo single, released February 4, 1974
Source for the tree : "Us And Them" US promo single
Various short edits during sax solos, no third verse, fade out during piano solo.
14 - Us And Them (Waters, Wright) - mono edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "The Dark Side Of The Moon" US promo EP, released 1973
Source for the tree : "Us And Them" US promo single
Same as previous edit: various short edits during sax solos, no third verse, fade out
during piano solo.
15 - Brain Damage / Eclipse (Waters) - demo
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "From the Other Side" RoIO CD
Fades in the middle of the song. No laughter after the first sentence. Guitar solo all along
the track. No voice during the bridge between "Brain Damage" and "Eclipse".
16 - Brain Damage (Waters) - outtake
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, November 1972
Primary source : "Live At Pompeii" film
Source for the tree : "Live At Pompeii" LaserDisc
Studio outtake with interview segments. This version has guitar parts similar to the demo
version.
17 - Brain Damage (Waters) - outtake
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, November 1972
Primary source : "Live At Pompeii" film
Source for the tree : "Live At Pompeii" LaserDisc
Length : 01:16
Studio outtake with interview segments. Slightly different bass line. Note that in the film
this track is inserted between the two "Us And Them" parts.
18 - Eclipse - "mysterious ending tiny music"
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, June 1972 - January 1973
Primary source : "The Dark Side of the Moon" album, released March 24, 1973
Source for the tree : "The Dark Side of the Moon" MFSL CD
At the very end of "The Dark Side of the Moon", you can hear at very low level (below
the tape hiss level) some notes of music. Some think it's a Beatles tune, some don't ;-).
Even if it's easier to remove it than keep it, all the remastered editions of the album have
this "default".
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation (studio). 17 Discs.
Volume 2 (CD3 - CD4): Pink Floyd Rarities 1969 - 1973
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 3
Compilation
Unknown
CD5
1 - Merry Xmas Song (uncredited)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "All Movement is Accomplished" RoIO CD
Impromptu song, probably sung by Nick Mason, with John Peel and Alan Stiles (Floyd
roadie to whom the song "Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast" on "Atom Heart Mother" album is
dedicated). Some say it was recorded during the Zabriskie Point sessions in Rome,
December 1969. Other think it's from 1974 or 1975. One thing is almost certain though:
it must have been recorded in December... ;-)
2 - Shine on you Crazy Diamond (Gilmour, Waters, Wright) - part 1
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : "Have A Cigar" French single, released 1975
Source for the tree : "Have A Cigar" French single
It fades out just before "Syd's theme" (the "four notes" guitar riff).
3 - Shine on you Crazy Diamond (Gilmour, Waters, Wright) - promo edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" promo single, released 1975
Source for the tree : "Anthology I" RoIO CD
This version fades in during Part 3 (last guitar solo before vocals), continues with the first
verse of Part 4 ("Remember when you were young ... you legend, you martyr, and
shine"), then jumps to Part 7 (third verse: "Nobody knows where you are ... for truth and
delusion, and shine"), and fades out during the end of Part 8.
4 - Shine on you Crazy Diamond (Gilmour, Waters, Wright) - 1981 edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : "A Collection of Great Dance Songs" compilation, released November 23, 1981
Source for the tree : "A Collection of Great Dance Songs" CD
Part 3 (last guitar solo before vocals) is skipped, Part 4 and Part 7 are linked (so that the
three verses are continuous), and there's a fade out after the last verse (just before Part
8).
5 - Shine on you Crazy Diamond (Gilmour, Waters, Wright) - UK short version
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : "Selected Tracks from Shine On" UK promo CD, released 1992
Source for the tree : "Selected Tracks from Shine On" UK promo CD
On the promo sampler, this version is called "radio edit", but it's in fact a short version of
the song (there is no "edit"): it fades in at the beginning of Part 4 ("Remember when you
were young ...") and fades out at the end of Part 5 (sax solo).
6 - Shine on you Crazy Diamond (Gilmour, Waters, Wright) - US short version
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : "Shine On - Selections from the Box" US promo CD, released 1992
Source for the tree : "Shine On - Selections from the Box" US promo CD
This version is also called "radio edit" on the US promo sampler, although it's slightly
different from the "radio edit" on the UK promo sampler. Again, there's no "edit" and it's
in fact a short version: it fades in during the end of Part 3 (last guitar solo before vocals)
and fades out early during Part 5 (sax solo).
7 - Shine on you Crazy Diamond (Gilmour, Waters, Wright) - "storm" mix
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy
Parts 1 to 9 linked together, remixed with storm noises in the background. It is said that
this track was remixed by or for the BBC, but it is probably a fake. However, it has
acquired a certain fame in the trading circle of Pink Floyd fans. We included it here, in
order to let you make your own opinion.
8 - Shine on you Crazy Diamond (Gilmour, Waters, Wright) - "to the galaxy"
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : "Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy" radio show
Source for the tree : unkown gen copy
During one of the scenes in the "Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy" radio series (an
adaptation of Douglas Adams' novel), the opening of "Shine on you Crazy Diamond" can
be heard in the background and one of the characters (Arthur) says "Ford, do you realize
that robot can hum like Pink Floyd ?".
9 - Have A Cigar (Waters) - short version
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : "Have A Cigar" Italian single, released 1975.
Source for the tree : "Have A Cigar" Italian single
Note that the various European releases of this single have shorter or longer versions:
the French promo juke-box single is 04:50 long (it's nearly the complete version), the
Belgian single is 04:24 long and the Italian single is 04:13 long. All these European
versions fade out during the final guitar solo.
10 - Have A Cigar (Waters) - stereo edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : "Have A Cigar" US single, released November 15, 1975
Source for the tree : "Have A Cigar" US single
Four bars intro instead of eight bars (two small edits in the guitar and keyboards first
themes), plus an early fade out during the final guitar solo.
11 - Have A Cigar (Waters) - mono edit
Recorded : London, Abbey Road Studios, January - July 1975
Primary source : "Have A Cigar" US promo single, released November 15, 1975
Source for the tree : "Have A Cigar" US promo single
Same edit as above: four bars intro instead of eight bars, plus an early fade out during
the final guitar solo.
CD6
1 - "Animals" radio advert
Recorded : ?
Primary source : radio broadcast, 1977
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from radio broadcast
2 - Pigs on the Wing (Waters) - parts 1 & 2
Recorded : London, Britannia Row Studios, 1976
Primary source : "Animals" 8-tracks cartridge, released January 1977
Source for the tree : "Gold Top" Snowy White's compilation CD
On the US 8-tracks cartridge release of the "Animals" album, both parts of "Pigs on the
Wing" were linked by a guitar solo played by Snowy White. This enhanced track was only
released on CD in 1995, on Snowy White's compilation "Gold Top".
3 - Pigs (Three Different Ones) (Waters) - short version
Recorded : London, Britannia Row Studios, 1976
Primary source : "Pigs (Three Different Ones")" Brazilian promo single, released 1977
Source for the tree : "Pigs (Three Different Ones)" Brazilian promo single
This version fades out after the 2nd verse.
4 - The Wall - "loop message"
Recorded : April - November 1979
Primary source : "The Wall" album, released November 30, 1979
Source for the tree : "The Wall" MFSL CD
Roger says two bits of sentence at the very end and the very beginning of "The Wall".
Some understand: "Isn't this where Ö we came in ?", others understand: "Somebody
spoke Ö we came in".
5 - Another Brick In The Wall part 2 (Waters) - single version
Recorded : April - November 1979
Primary source : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" single, released November 16, 1979
Source for the tree : "Anthology I" RoIO CD
This version has four extra bars at the beginning (rhythm guitar intro that doesn't appear
on the album because of the abrupt transition between "The Happiest Days of our Lives"
and "Another Brick in the Wall part 2") and fades out during the guitar solo.
6 - Another Brick In The Wall part 2 (Waters) - 1981 single version
Recorded : April - November 1979
Primary source : "A Collection of Great Dance Songs" compilation, released November 23, 1981
Source for the tree : "A Collection of Great Dance Songs" CD
Same four bars intro as the original single version, but it fades out later, after the end of
the guitar solo (during the teacher's shouts).
7 - Empty Spaces - "backwards message"
Recorded : April - November 1979
Primary source : "The Wall" album, released November 30, 1979
Source for the tree : "The Wall" MFSL CD
There's a backwards message at the start of "Empty Spaces": "Congratulations, you have
just discovered the secret message. Please send your answer at the Funny Farm, care of
Old Pink, Chalfont". Then David shouts "Roger, Carolyne on the phone".
8 - Young Lust (Waters, Gilmour) - single version
Recorded : April - November 1979
Primary source : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" Italian single, released 1979
Source for the tree : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" Italian single
+ "Off The Wall" US radio promo EP
This version has some unreleased intro bars (on the album the track starts with the
lyrics) and doesn't fade out with the phone call. Note that there's a special US promo mix
(on "Off The Wall" radio promo EP) that doesn't have the intro bars, but has the same
ending.
9 - One of my Turns (Waters) - single version
Recorded : April - November 1979
Primary source : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" single, released November 16, 1979
Source for the tree : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" single
No intro crossfade with "Young Lust" (no phone tone at the beginning) nor outro
crossfade with "Don't Leave Me Now".
10 - Comfortably Numb (Gilmour, Waters) - demo
Recorded : 1978
Primary source : BBC Radio One interview with David Gilmour, broadcast July 28, 1992
Source for the tree : "Total Eclipse" RoIO CD
David Gilmour's demo tape.
11 - Comfortably Numb (Gilmour, Waters) - edit
Recorded : April - November 1979
Primary source : "Run Like Hell" US single, released June 1980
Source for the tree : "Run Like Hell" US single
Final guitar solo is stuck to the end of the first verse (no first guitar solo, no second
verse).
12 - Run Like Hell (Gilmour, Waters) - single version
Recorded : April - November 1979
Primary source : "Run Like Hell" US single, released June 1980
Source for the tree : "Run Like Hell" US single
No croud noise during intro and outro. Only one guitar theme before the first "Run, run,
run, runÖ" instead of two, but it is repeated twice at the end (after the scream) instead
of once. The "hunt" part is edited.
13 - Run Like Hell (Gilmour, Waters) - promo mix
Recorded : April - November 1979
Primary source : "Off The Wall" radio promo, released 1979
Source for the tree : "Off The Wall" radio promo
No crowd noise during intro and outro. Intro theme (before the guitar theme) is twice as
long as on the album. Guitar theme is repeated twice after the final scream, instead of
once.
14 - Money (Waters) - 1981 version
Recorded : London, New Roydonia Studios, 1981
Primary source : "A Collection of Great Dance Songs" compilation, released November 23, 1981
Source for the tree : "A Collection of Great Dance Songs" CD
This is a new version, re-recorded by David Gilmour due to contractual reason.
15 - Money (Waters) - 1981 edit
Recorded : London, New Roydonia Studios, 1981
Primary source : "Money" UK single, released 1982
Source for the tree : "Anthology I" RoIO CD
No sax solo.
16 - When the Tigers Broke Free (Waters) - single version
Recorded : 1982
Primary source : "When the Tigers Broke Free" single, released July 26, 1982
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - The Wall Berlin '90" promo CD
This song is the only soundtrack extract from "The Wall" movie that was eventually
officially released. In the film, it was split into two parts (with more choir intro and
outro). The orchestra is mixed louder on this version, which also has more drum rolls.
17 - Bring the Boys Back Home (Waters) - single version
Recorded : 1982
Primary source : "When the Tigers Broke Free" single, released July 26, 1982
Source for the tree : "Total Eclipse" RoIO CD
This song was re-recorded for the film, without Roger's voice (there's only the choir). On
this single version, the orchestral bridge is longer than on the album version (also note
that the flute theme is not in the film version) and with three reprises of "Bring the boys
back home", when there's only one on the album.
18 - "The Final Cut" radio avert
Recorded : ?
Primary source : WKLS radio broadcast, Atlanta, March 17, 1983
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from radio broadcast
19 - Not Now John (Waters) - obscured version
Recorded : 1982
Primary source : "Not Now John" single, released April 30, 1983
Source for the tree : "A CD Full of Secrets" CD
Since the original version has lyrics that say "F*** all that", David Gilmour came back in
the studio to make a radio-friendly version ("Stuff all that") for the single release. Note
that they just recorded "Stuff all that" loud enough to drown the original, which is still
there. The intro is slightly different from the album version (no laugh), and this version
fades out before the lyrics "Where's the fucking bar John?".
20 - Not Now John (Waters) - promo edit
Recorded : 1982
Primary source : "Not Now John" Argentinian promo single, released 1983
Source for the tree : "Not Now John" Argentinian promo single
This version is not obscured (it has the F*** word). It begins directly with the vocals (no
intro), and the lines "Hold on John, I think there's something good on Ö it could be
reusable shows" were skipped.
21 - The Hero's Return (Waters) - parts 1 & 2
Recorded : 1982
Primary source : "Not Now John" single, released April 30, 1983
Source for the tree : "Total Eclipse" RoIO CD
The second part, with additional lyrics, is only available on the single.
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation (studio). 17 Discs.
Volume 3 (CD5 - CD6): Pink Floyd Rarities 1974 - 1983
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 4
Compilation
Unknown
CD7
1 - Learning to Fly (Gilmour, Ezrin, Carin, Moore) - demo
Recorded : 1986
Primary source : BBC Radio One interview with David Gilmour, broadcast July 28, 1992
Source for the tree : 3rd gen copy from BBC Radio One broadcast
This is Jon Carin's demo. Jon Carin met David Gilmour in 1985, during "Live Aid". He
played keyboards with the Floyd (in studio and on tour) from 1986 to 1994. He also
played keyboards, guitars and did some vocals on Roger Waters' "In The Flesh" Tour, in
1999 and 2000.
2 - Learning to Fly (Gilmour, Ezrin, Carin, Moore) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "Learning to Fly" US single, released September 15, 1987
Source for the tree : "Learning to Fly" UK CD single
The instrumental part before the last verse ("Above the planet on a wing and a prayer
...") is edited (6 bars instead of 10 during the "checklist"). This version also fades out
slightly earlier than the regular one.
3 - The Dogs of War (Gilmour, Moore) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "A Momentary Lapse of Reason Official Tour CD" US promo, released 1988
Source for the tree : "A Momentary Lapse of Reason Official Tour CD"
Shorter intro (2 themes instead of 8). Note that the end is not mixed with the beginning
of "One Slip" as on the album.
4 - One Slip (Gilmour, Manzanera) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "Learning to Fly" UK single, released October 3, 1987
Source for the tree : "Learning to Fly" UK CD single
This version begins with the first drum hit (the "clocks noises" part of the album version
is skipped). The rototom intro is edited (4 themes instead of 8) and doesn't have the
background keyboards. The central part with bass solo is edited (2 themes instead of 4).
The last chorus is repeated and the fade out happens during the second one (on the
album version, after the last chorus, there's a reprise of the bass solo and then the song
fades out).
5 - On the Turning Away (Gilmour, Moore) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "On the Turning Away" UK promo single, released December 7, 1987
Source for the tree : ?
The quiet fretless bass lines, just before the last verse, are edited out. The first part of
the final guitar solo is edited. Early fade out.
6 - The Dogs of War (Gilmour, Moore) - live
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "One Slip" single, released 1988
Source for the tree : "A Momentary Lapse of Reason Official Tour CD"
7 - On the Turning Away (Gilmour, Moore) - live
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "On the Turning Away" 12" single, released November 24, 1987
Source for the tree : "On the Turning Away" CD single
It was filmed and used for "On the Turning Away" video.
8 - One Slip (Gilmour, Manzanera) - live 05:24
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "One Slip" video
Source for the tree : "One Slip" video
Note that this live version was never officially released. It's only available from TV
broadcasts.
9 - Run Like Hell (Waters, Gilmour) - live
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "On the Turning Away" single, released November 24, 1987
Source for the tree : "On the Turning Away" CD single
10 - Wearing the Inside Out (Wright, Moore) - LP version
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "The Division Bell" LP, released March 30, 1994
Source for the tree : "The Division Bell" LP
This LP version is different from the CD version, with a slight change in the lyrics: the
first lines of the second verse ("I murmured a vow ... when I think aloud") were added to
the first verse, and the rest of the second verse ("Extinguished by the light ... with an
empty smile") was left out, so that the LP version has a longer first verse, and no second
verse between "This bleeding heart's not beating much" and "I'm creeping back to life...".
11 - Take it Back (Gilmour, Ezrin, Samson, Laird-Clowes) - edit
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" single, released May 16, 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" CD single
Edits during the intro (5 chords instead of 9), the central part (8 chords instead of 16)
and the outro (4 chords instead of 8).
12 - Take it Back (Gilmour, Ezrin, Samson, Laird-Clowes) - extended
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" French promo single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" French promo single, released 1994
Extended ending.
13 - Keep Talking (Gilmour, Wright, Samson) - radio edit
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK single, released October 17, 1994
Source for the tree : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK CD single
Late fade in (the first 24 seconds from the original version are missing). The guitar and
keyboards solos in the middle of the song are both shortened. Early fade out.
CD8
1 - Lost for Words (Gilmour, Samson) - clean version
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "Lost for Words" US promo single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "Lost for Words" US promo CD
The "f***" word in "please gonna f*** myself" is censored by a "beep". Early fade out.
2 - High Hopes (Gilmour, Samson) - radio edit
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK single, released October 17, 1994
Source for the tree : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK CD single
Edits during the piano/bells intro (2 themes instead of 4), during the central instrumental
part with acoustic guitar (2 themes instead of 4) and during the ending guitar solo. Note
that the "radio edit" on the French single is 5 seconds shorter (2 more bells ringings were
cut).
3 - High Hopes - "phone call"
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "The Division Bell" album, released March 30, 1994
Source for the tree : "The Division Bell" CD
At the very end of "The Division Bell" album, there's a phone conversation between Steve
O'Rourke (Floyd's manager) and Charlie (Polly Samson's son; Polly married David Gilmour
in 1994). This conversation was probably incidentally recorded by the answering machine
at Gilmour's house.
4 - David Gilmour interview
Recorded : March 26, 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" Australian promo single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" Australian promo CD
This is an "answers only" interview, where David Gilmour is supposed to answer 8
different questions. The questions are available on a separate sheet provided with the
promo CD:
Question 1: Where was your new album, The Division Bell, recorded ?
Question 2: How was the recording of this album different from the previous Pink Floyd
album ?
Question 3: How did you arrive at the title The Division Bell ?
Question 4: Do you enjoy putting on such enormous concert events ?
Question 5: Let's talk about the songs on the album. On "What Do You Want From Me"
the music was written by you and Richard and the lyrics were written by you
and Polly Samson. Could you tell us how this wame about ?
Question 6: There's an incredible instrumental on the album. Could you explain how you
came up with the music and the title to "Marooned" ?
Question 7: How did you come up with "Wearing The Inside Out". I see that Dick Parry
plays saxophone on this song ?
Question 8: "Keep Talking" is an amazing song. It's being played on the radio almost
constantly. Are you happy with the response that song is getting ?
5 - Soundscape (uncredited)
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette, released 1995
Source for the tree : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette
This track consists of various ambient noises and is probably an extract of the (longer)
tape that was played before the Floyd shows during the Division Bell Tour. Somewhere in
the middle, an extract from "Cluster One" can be heard. It is not available on
"P*U*L*S*E" CD and LP releases.
6 - Astronomy DominÈ (Barrett) - live
Recorded : live, Miami, Joe Robbie Stadium, April 30, 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" single, released May 16, 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" CD single
First song from the first night of the Division Bell Tour.
7 - One of These Days (Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour) - live
Recorded : live, Hannover, Niedersachsenstadion, August 17, 1994
Primary source : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK CD single
8 - Wish You Were Here (Waters, Gilmour) - live edit
Recorded : live, Rome, Cinecitta, September 20, 1994
Primary source : "Wish You Were Here" French promo single, released 1995
Source for the tree : "Wish You Were Here" French promo CD
This is an edit of the "P*U*L*S*E" version: it fades in at the beginning of the acoustic
guitar solo (at 01:42 on "P*U*L*S*E" CD), and there's a short edit during the last
guitar/voice duo, after the last verse (the segment 04:29-04:43 on the "P*U*L*S*E" CD
version was cut).
9 - Coming Back to Life (Gilmour) - live edit
Recorded : live, London, Earls Court, October 13, 1994
Primary source : "Coming Back to Life" US promo single, released 1995
Source for the tree : "Coming Back to Life" US promo CD
This is an edit of the "P*U*L*S*E" version: the instrumental guitar intro is missing (the
song begins with the first lines "Where were you ..."), and it ends just after the last verse
(skipping the final guitar solo).
10 - One of These Days (Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour) - live
Recorded : live, London, Earls Court, October 16 & 20, 1994
Primary source : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette, released 1995
Source for the tree : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette
This is not the same live version as the one available on "High Hopes / Keep Talking"
single. It's available on "P*U*L*S*E" cassette and LP releases only.
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation
Volume 4 (CD7 - CD8): Pink Floyd Rarities 1987 - 1994
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 5
Compilation
Unknown
CD9
"San Francisco"
1 - Interstellar Overdrive (Barrett, Waters, Wright, Mason)
Recorded : London, Thompson Recording Studios, October 31, 1966
Primary source : "San Francisco" film, released 1968
Source for the tree : 1st gen copy from the film
This version is also rumoured as to have been recorded in Syd Barrett's garage.
"Tonite Let's All Make Love in London"
2 - Interstellar Overdrive (Barrett, Waters, Wright, Mason)
3 - Nick's Boogie (Barrett, Mason, Wright, Waters) 11:43
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, January 11-12, 1967
Primary source : "Tonite Let's All Make Love In London... Plus" CD, released 1990
Source for the tree : "In London 1966*1967" CD
The original soundtrack album was released July 19, 1968, and contained a 3 minutes
extract from "Interstellar Overdrive". The full length version of "Interstellar Overdrive"
was released for the first time in 1990, on "Tonite Let's All Make Love In London... Plus"
CD, along with the unreleased "Nick's Boogie".
"The Committee" (Parts 1`-8)
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, April 1968
Primary source : "The Committee" film, released 1968
Source for the tree : 1st gen copy from the film
The first track of the film was in fact recorded backwards. We inverted this track, so that
you can hear the song as it was recorded (track 4). Track 5 is the track as it appears in
the film.
Note that part 7 is an early version of "Careful With That Axe, Eugene".
"More"
13 - Main Theme (Waters, Wright, Gilmour) - film version
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, March 1969
Primary source : "More" film, released 1969
Source for the tree : "More" video
On the film, the slide guitar that can be heard on the regular version was edited out.
14 - Seabirds (Waters)
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, March 1969
Primary source : "More" film, released 1969
Source for the tree : "More" video
This song doesn't appear on the album.
15 - Cymbaline (Waters) - film version
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, March 1969
Primary source : "More" film, released 1969
Source for the tree : "More" video
This version has alternate lyrics, and the vocals are sung in a very different way than on
the album ("head voice").
16 - Hollywood (Gilmour)
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, March 1969
Primary source : "More" film, released 1969
Source for the tree : "More" video
Short instrumental track, not included on the album.
CD10
1 - "More" outtakes
Recorded : London, Sound Techniques Studios, March 1969
Primary source : BBC broadcast ("Laying Down Tracks"), June 1969
Source for the tree : unknown gen from BBC broadcast
This is in fact a documentary about the multi-track recording technique, broadcast by the
BBC in June 1969, under the title "Laying Down Tracks". One can hear outtakes from the
"More" recording sessions: first, some unreleased instrumental music, then "Cirrus Minor"
and at last the keyboards intro to "Main Theme".
On some RoIOs, this BBC docmumentary is wrongly referred as being "The Committee" soundtrack.
"Zabriskie Point"
2 - Heart Beat, Pig Meat (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright)
Recorded : Rome, November - December 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point" soundtrack, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD
3 - Heart Beat, Pig Meat (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright) - film version
Recorded : Rome, November - December 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point" film, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point" LaserDisc
Alternate mono mix. Extended intro (before the first organ notes). Sounds and
background noises are differently mixed (especially the orchestra snippets). The last part
is edited.
4 - Crumbling Land (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright)
Recorded : Rome, November - December 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point" soundtrack, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD
This song was described by David Gilmour as "a kind of country and western number
which he [Michelangelo Antonioni, the film's director] could have gotten done better by
any number of American bands. But he chose ours... Very strange".
5 - Crumbling Land (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright) - extended
Recorded : Rome, November - December 1969
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "Omay Yad" RoIO CD
This version is basically the same as the regular version from the soundtrack album, but
the ending with cars and street noises is uncut.
6 - Crumbling Land (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright) - film version
Recorded : Rome, November - December 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point" film, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point" LaserDisc
Alternate mono mix, with different vocal tracks.
7 - Come in Number 51, Your Time is Up (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright)
Recorded : Rome, November - December 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point" soundtrack, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD
"Careful With That Axe, Eugene" revisited.
8 - Come in Number 51, Your Time is Up (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright) - film version
Recorded : Rome, November - December 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point" film, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point" LaserDisc
Alternate mono mix, organ mixed louder, one guitar track edited out. Note that the
"reprise", after the abrupt cut, only appears on the LaserDisc version.
9 - Love Scene - Version 4 (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright)
Recorded : Rome, November 16, 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD, released 1997
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD
Pink Floyd made at least 6 attempts to compose music that could fit in the desert sex
sequence of the film. Finally, none of the Floyd's versions was chosen (the music
accompanying the love scene in the film was composed and played by Grateful Dead's
guitarist Jerry Garcia). Version 4 is a quiet instrumental piano piece, played by Rick
Wright.
10 - Love Scene - Version 6 (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright)
Recorded : Rome, November 16, 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD, released 1997
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD
Version 6 is a totally different approach than version 4. This is a blues jam, played by the
whole band, not very far from the blues number they used to play during their live
performances in 1970 and 1971.
11 - Unknown Song (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright)
Recorded : Rome, December 6, 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD, released 1997
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD
The acoustic guitar duo has some themes from "The Narrow Way Part 1". The bass lines
appearing in this outtake were later developed in "Atom Heart Mother" ("Funky Dung").
12 - Rain in the Country (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright)
Recorded : Rome, December 6, 1969
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "Omay Yad" RoIO CD
Alternate take from "Unknown Song" (same basic track, but different lead and overdubs,
different edits). The title "Rain In The Country" was probably given by the "Omay Yad"
RoIO LP manufacturers, where this outtake first surfaced.
13 - Country Song (Waters, Gilmour, Mason, Wright)
Recorded : Rome, December 12, 1969
Primary source : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD, released 1997
Source for the tree : "Zabriskie Point - Extended Soundtrack" CD
14 - Oenone (uncredited)
Recorded : Rome, November - December, 1969
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "Omay Yad" RoIO CD
"Oenone", from Greek mythology, is the name of a nymph deserted by her husband,
Paris, for Helen of troy. Some prefer to spell this outtake "Oneone", because it would be
pronounced "oh-nee-oh-nee", the same way as the end of Zabriskie Point's director
name, Michelangelo AntONIONI. This title was probably given by the "Omay Yad" RoIO
LP manufacturers, where this outtake first surfaced.
15 - Fingal's Cave (uncredited)
Recorded : Rome, November - December, 1969
Primary source : ?
Source for the tree : "Omay Yad" RoIO CD
"Fingal's Cave" is the name of a large cavern on Staffa islet in the Hebrides, West
Scotland. This title was probably given by the "Omay Yad" RoIO LP manufacturers, where
this outtake first surfaced.
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation
Volume 5 (CD9 - CD10): Soundtracks 1966 - 1969
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 6
Compilation
Unknown
CD11
"The Body"
1 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Our Song (Waters, Geesin)
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "Music from The Body" soundtrack, released November 28, 1970
Source for the tree : "Music from The Body" soundtrack CD
2 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Sea Shell and Stone (Waters)
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "Music from The Body" soundtrack, released November 28, 1970
Source for the tree : "Music from The Body" soundtrack CD
This is in fact the main theme of the soundtrack, that appears on several other tracks, in
different forms. This version is an acoustic song: acoustic guitar, bass and Roger Waters'
vocals.
3 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Sea Shell and Soft Stone (Waters, Geesin)
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "Music from The Body" soundtrack, released November 28, 1970
Source for the tree : "Music from The Body" soundtrack CD
Instrumental version of the main theme, with violins arranged by Ron Geesin.
4 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Breathe (Waters)
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "Music from The Body" soundtrack, released November 28, 1970
Source for the tree : "Music from The Body" soundtrack CD
This is not the song from "The Dark Side of the Moon" album, but curiously it also begins
with "Breathe in the air...". This is in fact "Sea Shell And Stone" part 2.
5 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Sea Shell and Stone (Waters) - film version
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "The Body" film, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume Three" RoIO CD
Alternate take, directly from the film. Note that there are sometimes two vocal lines
instead of one on the regular version. If you listen carefully, you can hear some birds in
the background, in fact this is exactly the same tape that was used at the beginning of
"More" (probably an Abbey Road standard tape, since the same birds can be heard on
songs from other artists, like the Beatles, the Kinks, Kate Bush...).
6 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Sea Shell and Soft Stone (Waters, Geesin) - film version
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "The Body" film, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume Three" RoIO CD
Alternate take, directly from the film.
7 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Breathe (Waters) - film version
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "The Body" film, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume Three" RoIO CD
Alternate take, directly from the film. Note that there are sometimes two vocal lines
instead of one on the regular version. The birds from "More" can be heard again in the
background.
8 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Chain of Life (Waters)
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "Music from The Body" soundtrack, released November 28, 1970
Source for the tree : "Music from The Body" soundtrack CD
9 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - The Womb Bit (Waters, Geesin)
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "Music from The Body" soundtrack, released November 28, 1970
Source for the tree : "Music from The Body" soundtrack CD
10 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Body Transport (Waters, Geesin)
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "Music from The Body" soundtrack, released November 28, 1970
Source for the tree : "Music from The Body" soundtrack CD
11 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Give Birth to a Smile (Waters)
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "Music from The Body" soundtrack, released November 28, 1970
Source for the tree : "Music from The Body" soundtrack CD
Another variation on the main theme. But this time, this is a song performed by all the
four Pink Floyd members.
12 - Roger Waters & Ron Geesin - Give Birth to a Smile (Waters) - film version
Recorded : 1970
Primary source : "The Body" film, released 1970
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume Three" RoIO CD
Alternate take, directly from the film. No female backing vocals.
"Live At Pompeii"
13 - "Live At Pompeii" radio advert #1
14 - "Live At Pompeii" radio advert #2
15 - "Live At Pompeii" radio advert #3
16 - "Live At Pompeii" radio advert #4
17 - "Live At Pompeii" radio advert #5
18 - "Live At Pompeii" radio advert #6
19 - "Live At Pompeii" radio advert #7
20 - "Live At Pompeii" goofy ad #1
21 - "Live At Pompeii" goofy ad #2
22 - "Live At Pompeii" goofy ad #3
23 - "Live At Pompeii" goofy ad #4
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "Radio Ads For Pompeii Movie" US promo EP, released 1974
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from "Radio Ads For Pompeii Movie" US promo EP
"La Vallee"
24 - Obscured by Clouds (Waters, Gilmour)
Recorded : France, Ch‚teau d'HÈrouville, 1972
Primary source : French radio broadcast, February 27, 1972
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from French radio broadcast
Outtake from "Obscured By Clouds" recording sessions. One can hear some keyboard
parts not appearing on the regular version.
25 - Free Four (Waters) - short version
Recorded : France, Ch‚teau d'HÈrouville, 1972
Primary source : "Free Four" US promo single, released July 10, 1972
Source for the tree : "Free Four" US promo single
Early fade out.
26 - Free Four (Waters) - film version
Recorded : France, Ch‚teau d'HÈrouville, 1972
Primary source : "La Vallee" film, released 1972
Source for the tree : 1st gen copy from "La Vallee" video
Directly from the film. This version has an extra verse.
27 - Instrumental (uncredited)
Recorded : France, Ch‚teau d'HÈrouville, 1972
Primary source : "La Vallee" film, released 1972
Source for the tree : 1st gen copy from "La Vallee" video
Directly from the film. This short instrumental track was not included on the album.
"Magritte"
28 - Roger Waters - Magritte Pt.1 (Waters)
29 - Roger Waters - Magritte Pt.2 (Waters)
30 - Roger Waters - Magritte Pt.3 (Waters)
31 - Roger Waters - Magritte Pt.4 (Waters)
32 - Roger Waters - Magritte Pt.5 (Waters)
33 - Roger Waters - Magritte Pt.6 (Waters)
34 - Roger Waters - Magritte Pt.7 (Waters)
35 - Roger Waters - Magritte Pt.8 (Waters, Gilmour)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "Magritte" documentary film, 1978
Source for the tree : "Magritte" video
From a biography of Belgian surrealist painter RenÈ Magritte. Although this documentary
was first released in 1978, it is possible that the music has been recorded several years
before. For instance, during Part 2, Part 3 and Part 4, the strange keyboards sounds are
very similar to those one can hear during "On The Run" sequence of "Live At Pompeii",
where Roger Waters is trying to get different sounds from the synthesizer (this could
make sense, since both "Magritte" and "Live At Pompeii" were directed by Adrian Maben).
Some attribute these low-pitched pulses to Adrian Maben himself, although he's not
credited as music composer for this documentary. The song that can be heard during
Part 5 and Part 6 seems to be an unreleased song performed by Pink Floyd. Part 8
contains an extract from "Obscured By Clouds".
Note that we didn't include the whole documentary soundtrack here, we just took the
snippets containing music by Roger Waters (most probably). So, parts of the
documentary are missing, but the music is uncut.
"The Hit"
36 - Roger Waters - The Hit (Waters, Clapton)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "The Hit" film, released 1985
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume Three" RoIO CD
The title track of this film was written and performed by Roger Waters and Eric Clapton.
CD12
"When the Wind Blows"
1 - Roger Waters - The Russian Missile (Waters)
2 - Roger Waters - Towers of Faith (Waters)
3 - Roger Waters - Hilda's Dream (Waters)
4 - Roger Waters - The American Bomber (Waters)
5 - Roger Waters - The Anderson Shelter (Waters)
6 - Roger Waters - The British Submarine (Waters)
7 - Roger Waters - The Attack (Waters)
8 - Roger Waters - The Fallout (Waters)
9 - Roger Waters - Hilda's Hair (Waters)
10 - Roger Waters - Folded Flags (Waters)
Recorded : 1986
Primary source : "When the Wind Blows" soundtrack, released October 30, 1986
Source for the tree : "When The Wind Blows" soundtrack CD
"White Of The Eye"
Nick Mason & Rick Fenn - White Of The Eye Pts.1- 34
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "White Of The Eye", released 1988
Source for the tree : "White Of The Eye" video
Part 5 is a song called ìSlim Jenkinsí Jointî, written by Booker T. & the MGs, and
performed by Nick Mason and Rick Fenn. During Part 13, one can hear a short extract
from a song by Hank Williams Jr., entitled "A Country Boy Can Survive".
Note that we didn't include the whole soundtrack here, we just took the snippets
containing music performed by Nick Mason and Rick Fenn. So, parts of the film are
missing, but the music is uncut.
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation
Volume 6 (CD11 - CD12): Soundtracks 1970 - 1988
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 7
Compilation
Unknown
CD13
"La Carrera Panamericana"
1 - Run Like Hell (Gilmour, Waters)
Recorded : New York, Nassau Coliseum, August 19-23, 1988
Primary source : "La Carrera Panamericana" film, released 1992
Source for the tree : "La Carrera Panamericana" LaserDisc
This version of "Run Like Hell" is in fact a short extract from the "Delicate Sound of
Thunder" version, with a new recorded ending.
2 - Country Theme (Gilmour)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "La Carrera Panamericana" film, released 1992
Source for the tree : "La Carrera Panamericana" LaserDisc
3 - Small Theme (Gilmour)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "La Carrera Panamericana" film, released 1992
Source for the tree : "La Carrera Panamericana" LaserDisc
4 - Big Theme (Gilmour)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "La Carrera Panamericana" film, released 1992
Source for the tree : "La Carrera Panamericana" LaserDisc
5 - Carrera Slow Blues (Gilmour, Mason, Wright)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "La Carrera Panamericana" TV broadcast
Source for the tree : 2nd gen copy from "La Carrera Panamericana" TV broadcast
This song was taken from the BBC TV broadcast of the film (it's not on the LaserDisc or
video release, although it's listed at the end of the tracklist). Since the music was slightly
re-organised on the broadcast version of the film, the talking that can be heard during
"Carrera Slow Blues" is in fact a part of the talking that's placed somewhere during "Big
Theme" on the LaserDisc version.
6 - Mexico '78 (Gilmour)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "La Carrera Panamericana" film, released 1992
Source for the tree : "La Carrera Panamericana" LaserDisc
7 - Pan Am Shuffle (Gilmour, Mason, Wright) - full length version 08:09
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "La Carrera Panamericana" film, released 1992
Source for the tree : "La Carrera Panamericana" LaserDisc
and 2nd gen copy from "La Carrera Panamericana" TV broadcast
The song "Pan Am Shuffle" appears at different places during the film: first at the
beginning of the film, then during the ending credits. Besides that, the length of the
credits varies on the different versions of the film (LaserDisc, video or TV broadcast):
since the song fades out on both LaserDisc and video releases, only the broadcast
version of the film contains the very end of the song. So we combined several parts of
the LaserDisc and the TV broadcast, to have the full length version.
"Ruby Takes a Trip"
8-20 - David Gilmour - Ruby Takes A Trip Pts.1-13
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "Ruby Takes a Trip" TV broadcast, 1992
Source for the tree : "Take a Trip to the X-Files" RoIO CD
Part 9 and Part 10 contain a monotonal piece of music, with a slide guitar theme that's
not very far from "One Of These Days". Part 11 is "On The Run" revisited.
Note that we didn't include the whole soundtrack here, we just took the snippets
containing music by David Gilmour. So, parts of the film are missing, but the music is
uncut.
"The Art of Tripping"
2-25 - David Gilmour - The Art of Tripping Pts.1-5 (Gilmour) 00:15
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "The Art of Tripping" TV broadcast, 1993
Source for the tree : unknown gen copy from "The Art of Tripping" TV broadcast
The musical score by David Gilmour only consists of short snippets. Note that Part 4
contains the same piece of music as Part 7 and Part 8 of "Ruby Takes A Trip".
"The Colors of Infinity"
26 - 45 David Gilmour - The Colors of Infinity Pt.1-20 (Gilmour)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "The Colors of Infinity" video, released 1997
Source for the tree : 1St gen copy from "The Colors of Infinity" video
Length :
This film is a documentary about fractals and The Mandelbrot set. For this soundtrack,
David Gilmour re-used some pieces from his previous soundtracks. Part 2 and Part 20
contain the same piece of music as Part 9 and Part 10 of "Ruby Takes A Trip" (slide
guitar theme, a la "One Of These Days"). Part 6 is basically the same as Part 2 and Part 3
of "Ruby Takes A Trip" (slow theme). Part 9 and Part 10 contain the same piece of music
as Part 3 of "The Art Of Tripping" (keyboards with high pitched guitar on the top, a la
"Marooned"). Part 15 is the same as Part 11 of "Ruby Takes A Trip" ("On The Run"
revisited). Note that the theme that can be heard during Part 12 is very similar to the
central part of "High Hopes".
Note that we didn't include the whole documentary soundtrack here, we just took the
snippets containing music by David Gilmour. So, parts of the documentary are missing,
but the music is uncut.
CD14
"The Dybbuk of the Holy Apple Field"
1 - Roger Waters - Knocking on Heaven's Door (Dylan)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "The Dybbuk from the Holy Apple Field" film, released 1998
Source for the tree : "The Dybbuk of the Holy Apple Field" film
"La Leggenda del Pianista Sull Oceano"
2 - Roger Waters - Lost Boys Calling (Morricone, Waters)
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "La Leggenda del Pianista Sull Oceano" Italian soundtrack, released 1998
Source for the tree : "La Leggenda del Pianista Sull Oceano" Italian soundtrack CD
This song contains the theme used throughout the rest of the film, composed by Ennio
Morricone. For "Lost Boys Calling", Roger Waters wrote the lyrics and probably did the
arrangement.
3 - Roger Waters - Lost Boys Calling (Morricone, Waters) - new version
Recorded : ?
Primary source : "Legend Of 1900" soundtrack, released 1999
Source for the tree : "Legend Of 1900" soundtrack CD
The Italian film was released worldwide in 1999, with the English title "Legend Of 1900".
A new soundtrack album ("Legend Of 1900") was released, and the version of "Lost Boys
Calling" is slightly different from the version on the Italian soundtrack. The vocals were
re-recorded, and a guitar solo by Edward Van Halen was added. Curiously, there's also a
slight change in the lyrics: during the last verse, Roger sings "when I hear those seabirds
cry", while on the Italian soundtrack version, it's "when she hears those seabirds cry".
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation
Volume 7 (CD13 - CD14): Soundtracks 1992 - 1999
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 8
Compilation
Unknown
CD15
1 - Jokers Wild - Why Do Fools Fall in Love (uncredited)
2 - Jokers Wild - Walk like a Man (uncredited)
3 - Jokers Wild - Don't Ask Me (What I Say) (uncredited)
4 - Jokers Wild - Big Girls Don't Cry (uncredited)
5 - Jokers Wild - Beautiful Delilah (uncredited)
Recorded : 1965
Primary source : "Jokers Wild" mini LP, released 1965
Source for the tree : "Jokers Wild" RoIO CDR
Jokers Wild was a band formed during the mid-60s, featuring David Gilmour. The other
musicians were John Gordon (guitar), Clive Welham (drums), Tony Sainty (bass) and
David Altham (vocals). In 1965, they recorded a one-sided mini LP with these 5 songs.
Note that David Gilmour played in other bands before joining Jokers Wild: The
Newcomers (early 60s) and then The Ramblers (in 1962-1963).
6 - David Gilmour - There's No Way Out of Here (Baker) - stereo edit
Recorded : France, Superbear Studios, 1978
Primary source : "There's No Way Out of Here" UK single, released May 25, 1978
Source for the tree : "There's No Way Out of Here" US promo single
The second verse ("There are no answers here ...") and the second chorus ("There never
was there an answer ... without seeing") were deleted.
7 - David Gilmour - There's No Way Out of Here (Baker) - mono edit
Recorded : France, Superbear Studios, 1978
Primary source : "There's No Way Out of Here" US promo single, released August 19, 1978
Source for the tree : "There's No Way Out of Here" US promo single
Same edit as above: the second verse ("There are no answers here ...") and the second
chorus ("There never was there an answer ... without seeing") were deleted.
8 - David Gilmour - Like a Rolling Stone (Dylan)
Recorded : David Gilmour home studio, 1983
Primary source : BBC Radio One interview with David Gilmour, broadcast July 28, 1992
Source for the tree : "Solo Works Vol.2" RoIO
9 - David Gilmour - Blue Light (Gilmour) - edit
Recorded : Paris, Pathe-Marconi Studios, 1984
Primary source : "Blue Light" UK single, released February 13, 1984
Source for the tree : "Blue Light" US promo single
The instrumental part with percussion, just after the first chorus, is edited (4 bars instead
of 8). The organ solo (by Deep Purple's keyboardist Jon Lord) is edited (4 bars instead of
8).
10 - David Gilmour - Blue Light (Gilmour) - vocal version
Recorded : Paris, Pathe-Marconi Studios, 1984
Primary source : "Blue Light" 12" promo single, released 1984
Source for the tree : "Blue Light" 12" promo single
This is an extended and remixed version. The new mix is obvious, especially on
percussion, vocal lines and guitar effects. There are 8 guitar themes added just before
the first verse. After the organ solo, there's a new instrumental part with bass and
percussion. The final guitar solo is extended.
11 - David Gilmour - Blue Light (Gilmour) - instrumental version
Recorded : Paris, Pathe-Marconi Studios, 1984
Primary source : "Blue Light" 12" promo single, released 1984
Source for the tree : "Blue Light" 12" promo single
This is another extended version, almost totally instrumental (one can hear "she's a blue
light" somewhere though). The structure is completely different from the previous
extended version.
12 - Roger Waters - For the First Time Today (Waters) - parts 1 & 2
Recorded : Olympic, Eel Pie & the Billiard Room, February - December 1983
Primary source : "5.06 am (Every Strangers Eyes)" single, released June 1984
Source for the tree : "Selections from the Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" promo sampler
Part 1 and Part 2 are linked on this version, while there are in different places on the
album (with Part 2 on side one and Part 1 on side two!). The end of Part 2 fades early
(just at the beginning of the "stay with me" sequence).
13 - Roger Waters - 5.01 am (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking) (Waters) - extended 05:22
Recorded : Olympic, Eel Pie & the Billiard Room, February - December 1983
Primary source : "5.01 am (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking)" 12" single, released 1984
Source for the tree : "5.01 am (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking)" 12" single
There's an alternate guitar solo in the middle of the song, followed by a sax solo that isn't
on the album version. The last part with the repeated female vocal lines "these are the
pros and cons of hitchhiking" has 2 added lines (just after "oh babe, I must be dreaming
again"): the first one with a saxophone bit, the second one with a guitar bit. The
following lines are the same as on the album.
14 - Roger Waters - 5.06 am (Every Strangers Eyes) (Waters) - edit
Recorded : Olympic, Eel Pie & the Billiard Room, February - December 1983
Primary source : "5.06 am (Every Strangers Eyes)" single, released June 1984
Source for the tree : "Selections from the Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" promo sampler
On the album version, right at the beginning of the song, there are two guys that can be
heard in the background, asking to turn the Juke Box down. One of the two guys says
"hey, turn that f*** Juke Box down". This sentence was edited out on the single version.
15 - Roger Waters - Across the Universe (Lennon)
Recorded : London, BBC TV, December 5, 1985
Primary source : "Tribute to John Lennon" BBC TV show
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume One" RoIO CD
This version features Andy Fairweather-Low on guitar.
16 - Roger Waters - Radio K.A.O.S. - "loop message"
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." album, released 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio K.A.O.S." CD
The very end and the very start of "Radio K.A.O.S." have a sentence by Jim Ladd: "That's
... back to the beginning".
17 - Roger Waters - Radio Waves (Waters) - edit
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio Waves" single, released May 11, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
Shorter intro, without the words of Jim Ladd. Early fade out.
18- Roger Waters - Radio Waves (Waters) - extended
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio Waves" 12" single, released May 11, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
Jim Ladd's words at the very beginning were edited out. The intro has 4 more bars. An
instrumental part was added between the intro and the first verse (one instrumental
chorus, one instrumental verse and one chorus with female vocals, singing "radio").
Another instrumental part was added between the second chorus and the guitar solo
(with some voices, including a loud sentence "The Fish Report with a Beat, in stereo!").
The ending is different from the regular version: there's no fade out, it ends abruptly with
the words "in stereo".
19 - Roger Waters - Me or Him (Waters) - demo
Recorded : the Billiard Room, 1986
Primary source : Rockline interview, broadcast September 21, 1987
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume One" RoIO CD
This demo is close to the final version.
CD16
1 - Roger Waters - The Fish Report With A Beat
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." Video EP, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
2 - Roger Waters - 4 Minutes (Waters) - video edit
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." Video EP, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
The intro is different from the regular version: the noises are different, and the vocals
begin with the female vocals ("Sometimes I feel like going home"), while the first verse
sung by Waters alone was deleted ("After a near miss on the plane ..."). Applause was
included at the end.
3 - Roger Waters - The Tide Is Turning (After Live Aid) (Waters) - video edit
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." Video EP, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
The ending of the song is different (the choir section ends very early, without fading out
with the morse code as on the album).
4 - Roger Waters - Going to Live in L.A. (Waters)
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio Waves" single, released May 11, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
5 - Roger Waters - Back to Radio (Waters)
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "The Tide is Turning (After Live Aid)" 12" UK single, released November 16, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
6 - Roger Waters - Money (Waters) - 1987 version
Recorded : the Billiard Room, July 14, 1987
Primary source : "The Tide is Turning (After Live Aid)" UK single, released November 16, 1987
& "Sunset Strip" single, released 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
This is a "live in the studio" version, sung by Paul Carrack. Applauses were added in the
mix.
7 - Roger Waters - Molly's Song (Waters) - live
Recorded : live, Inglewood, The Forum, September 20, 1987
Primary source : "Who Needs Information" US single, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
This song was sung by backing vocalist Doreen Chanter, during the "Radio KA.O.S. Tour".
No studio version has surfaced, although it is said that Roger Waters and the Bleeding
Heart Band recorded it for the follow up to "Radio K.A.O.S." (that was never released).
However, a short extract from this song can be heard in the background during "Four
Minutes", on the "Radio K.A.O.S." album.
8 - Roger Waters - Another Brick in the Wall part 2 (Waters) - 1990 version
Recorded : June 1990
Primary source : "The Wall Berlin '90" US promo, released 1990
Source for the tree : "The Wall Berlin '90" US promo CD
Studio version, re-recorded by Roger Waters & the Bleeding Heart Band some weeks
before the Berlin concert. Note that some background noises and guitar effects were
directly taken from the song "Is There Anybody Out There?" (on "The Wall" album).
9 - Roger Waters - Another Brick in The Wall part 2 (Waters) - live edit
Recorded : live, Berlin, Potsdamer Platz, June 18-21, 1990
Primary source : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" UK single, released September 10, 1990
Source for the tree : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" CD single
Lead vocals by Cyndi Lauper. The 2nd guitar solo and the following keyboards solos were
edited out. The song ends differently: the two lines "All in all it's just another brick in the
wall" and "All and all you're just another brick in the wall" were added right after the
guitar solo, to end the song abruptly (instead of the music fade-out and teacher's
screams on the live album).
10 - Roger Waters - Young Lust (Waters, Gilmour) - live edit
Recorded : live, Berlin, Potsdamer Platz, June 18-21, 1990
Primary source : "Pieces from The Wall" UK promo, released 1990
Source for the tree : "Pieces from the Wall" UK promo CD
Lead vocals by Bryan Adams. The intro is shorter (the guitar/drums part has 2 bars
instead of 4). The keyboard solo (between the guitar solo and the last chorus) was edited
out.
11 - Roger Waters - Run Like Hell (Gilmour, Waters) - potsdamer mix
Recorded : 1990
Primary source : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" UK single, released September 10, 1990
Source for the tree : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" CD single
This is a completely new version, with new vocals by Roger Waters and a lot of dance
and beatbox rhythms. Some samples from the original guitar riffs and the "hunt" part
were used. The rest is almost keyboards only.
12 - Roger Waters - The Tide is Turning (Waters) - live edit
Recorded : live, Berlin, Potsdamer Platz, June 18-21, 1990
Primary source : "The Tide is Turning" UK single, released November 19, 1990
Source for the tree : "The Tide is Turning" US promo CD
On this version, all the instrumental tracks were re-recorded (there's no orchestra or
piano, and the guitar lines are different from those on the live album). Only the vocals
from the guests were kept (Roger re-recorded his own vocals). The chorus after the
second verse was edited, and the following instrumental part was edited out. The last
chorus (with "oh, oh, oh, the tide is turning" without drums) has 2 lines instead of 8. This
version fades out early.
13 - Roger Waters - What God Wants part 1 (Waters) - video edit
Recorded : 1992
Primary source : "What God Wants part 1" single, released August 24, 1992
Source for the tree : "What God Wants part 1" CD single
The intro is shorter: the first part with female vocals ("What God wants, Got gets, God'll
help us all") was edited out, and the lines "What God wants, God gets" (during the first
guitar solo) are sung only twice (instead of 3 times on the album version).
14 - Roger Waters - Perfect Sense - "backwards message"
Recorded : 1992
Primary source : "Amused to Death" album, released 1992
Source for the tree : "Amused to Death" CD
Roger Waters wanted to use some lines and "breathing effects" from Stanley Kubrick's
"2001 : A Space Odyssey", but Kubrick refused. This explains the backward message at
the beginning on "Perfect Sense": "Julia, however, in the light and visions of the issues of
Stanley, we changed our minds. We have decided to include a backward message.
Stanley, for you, and for all the other book partners... (screamed sentence)".
15 - Roger Waters - Three Wishes (Waters) - radio edit
Recorded : 1992
Primary source : "Three Wishes" UK single, released 1992
Source for the tree : "Three Wishes" UK CD single
The instrumental intro before the first verse was edited out. The long instrumental part,
between the last vocal lines and the ending guitar solo, was edited out.
16 - Marianne Maithfull - Incarceration of a Flower Child (Waters)
Recorded : Oxnard, the Teatro, July 1998
Primary source : "Vagabond Ways" Marianne Faithfull album, released June 14, 1999
Source for the tree : "Vagabond Ways" Marianne Faithfull CD
This is the song Roger Waters "offered" to Marianne Faithfull. It was composed during
the early Floyd days, in 1968. It begins with the words "Do you remember me, how we
used to be...", exactly the same words than those used by Waters in "Your Possible
Pasts", on "The Final Cut" album. Note that this song features Roger on bass synth.
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation
Volume 8 (CD15 - CD16): David Gilmour and Roger Waters Rarities
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 9
Compilation
Unknown
CD17
1 - Zee - Confusion (Wright, Harris) - single version
Recorded : Cambridge, Rectory Studio, 1984
Primary source : "Confusion" UK single, released March 12, 1984
Source for the tree : "Confusion" UK single
This version is slightly remixed (some keyboard lines are added during the verses) and
edited (shorter intro, early fade out).
2 - Zee - Confusion (Wright, Harris) - extended
Recorded : Cambridge, Rectory Studio, 1984
Primary source : "Confusion" 12" UK single, released March 12, 1984
Source for the tree : "Confusion" 12" UK single
Longer intro and new extended ending.
3 - Zee - Eyes of a Gypsy (Harris)
Recorded : Cambridge, Rectory Studio, 1984
Primary source : "Confusion" UK single, released March 12, 1984
Source for the tree : "Confusion" UK single
Also available on the cassette release of "Identity" album.
4 - Zee - Eyes of a Gypsy (Harris) - dub
Recorded : Cambridge, Rectory Studio, 1984
Primary source : "Confusion" 12" UK single, released March 12, 1984
Source for the tree : "Confusion" 12" UK single
This version is completely remixed, with most of the vocal lines edited out.
5 - Rick Wright - Night of a Thousand Furry Toys (Wright, Moore) - inverted gravy mix
Recorded : France, Studio Harmonie, 1996
Primary source : "Broken China" UK promo CD, released 1996
Source for the tree : "Broken China" UK promo CD
Instrumental remix, by William Orbit with Matt Ducasse.
6 - Rick Wright - Runaway (Moore) - r. wright's lemonade mix
Recorded : France, Studio Harmonie, 1996
Primary source : "Broken China" UK promo CD, released 1996
Source for the tree : "Broken China" UK promo CD
Instrumental remix, by the Orb.
7 - Rick Wright - Runaway (Moore) - leggit dub
Recorded : France, Studio Harmonie, 1996
Primary source : "Broken China" UK promo CD, released 1996
Source for the tree : "Broken China" UK promo CD
Another instrumental remix, by the Orb.
8 - Nick Mason & Rick Fenn - Lie for a Lie (Fenn, Mason, Peyronel) - extended
Recorded : London, Britannia Row Studios N1 & Basement Studios SW14, 1985
Primary source : "Lie for a Lie" 12" single, released 1985
Source for the tree : "Lie for a Lie" 12" single
The intro has four bars instead of two. During the verses, soft keyboards (strings sound)
are added in the background. The second chorus is extended, with a new part during
which David Gilmour and the female choir are answering to each other. After the third
chorus, there's a new acoustic guitar solo.
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation
Volume 9 (CD17): Rick Wright and Nick Mason Rarities
Secret Rarities (1983-1993)
Unknown
Unknown
Like A Rolling Stone (David Gilmour demo 1983)
Like A Rolling Stone (David Gilmour demo 1983 - FM source)
Learning To Fly (Jon Carin demo 1986)
Learning To Fly (Jon Carin demo 1986 - FM source)
The Dogs Of War (demo 1986)
Signs Of Life (outtake 1986)
Untitled #1 (demo 1993)
Untitled #2 (demo 1993)
Untitled #3 (demo 1993)
Untitled #4 (demo 1993) (incl. What Do You Want From Me)
Untitled #1 (outtake 1993)
Wearing The Inside Out (outtake 1993)
The Instrumental Suite (outtake 1993)
Cluster One
Marooned
Untitled (incl. High Hopes)
At Dawn
London
UK
Flaming
Scarecrow
The Gnome
Matilda Mother
Vegetable Man
Scream Thy Last Scream
Pow R. Toc. H.
Jugband Blues
Murderistic Woman
Massed Gadgets Of Hercules
Let There Be More Light
Julia Dream
Point Me At The Sky
Baby Blue
Embryo
Interstellar Overdrive
Daybreak
Cymbaline
The Beginning
Beset By Creatures Of The Deep
Narrow Way
Original FM Broadcasts
t1-4: Recorded at the Playhouse Theatre, London, Sept. 25, 1967 "Top Gear"
t5-8: Recorded at Maida Vale Studios, London, Dec. 20, 1967 "Top Gear"
t9-12: Recorded at 201 Piccadilly, Studio 1, London, June 25, 1968 "Top Gear"
t13-16: Recorded at Maida Vale Studios, London, Dec. 2, 1968 "Top Gear"
t17-21: Recorded at the Paris Cinema, London, May 12, 1969 "Top Gear"
Complete Top Gear Session 67-69
London
UK
Flaming
Apples and Oranges
Scarecrow
The Gnome
Mathilda Mother
Vegetable Man
Pow R. Toc H.
Scream Thy Last Scream
Jugband Blues
Julia Dream
Let There Be More Light
Murderistic Women
The Massed Gadgets of Hercules
Point Me at the Sky
Baby Blue Shuffle in D Major
Embryo
Interstellar Overdrive
Daybreak
Cymbaline
Green is the Colour
Careful with that Axe, Eugene
The Narrow Way/Part Three
Pink Floyd The Complete Top Gear Sessions 1967-1969
This 2 CD set represents Pink Floyd's Top Gear sessions on the BBC between 30 Sep 1967 and 12 May 1969. Quality is generally very good, although there is some hiss on some tracks.
With - Without Sessions 67-69
London
UK
Complete BBC Broadcasts
London
UK
Jan 1967- Sept 71
Disc 1
Interstellar Overdrive
Mathilda Mother
Pow R Toc H
Astronomy Domine
Interstellar Overdrive w/interview
Reaction in G
Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
Flaming
Apples and Oranges
Scarecrow
The Gnome
Mathilda Mother
Vegetable Man
Scream Thy Last Scream
Pow R Toc H
Jugband Blues
Disc 2
Murderistic Women (aka Careful...)
The Massed Gadgets of Hercules (aka Saucerful)
Let there be More Light
Julia Dream
Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
Point Me at the Sky
Baby Blue shuffle in D Minor (aka the Narrow Way Part 1)
The Embryo
Interstellar Overdrive
Daybreak (aka Grantchester Meadows)
Cymbaline
The Beginning (aka Green is the Colour)
Beset By Creatures of the Deep (aka Careful...)
The Narrow Way Part 3
Disc 3
Interstellar Overdrive
Moonhead
The Embryo
Green is the Colour
Careful With That Axe Eugene
If
Atom Heart Mother
Disc 4
The Embryo
Blues
Fat Old Sun
One of These Days
Echoes
Disc 1 Tracks 1,2: UFO Club London Jan 27, 1967 BBC TV "Scene Special"
Disc 1 Tracks 3,4: BBC Television Centre London May 14 1967 "Look of the Week"
Disc 1 Track 5: BBC Radio London July 1967
Disc 1 Tracks 6,7: Cosmopolitan Ballroom Carlisle UK July 23, 1967
Disc 1 Tracks 8-12: Playhouse Theatre London, Sep 25, 1967 "Top Gear"
Disc 1 Tracks 12-16: Maida Vale Studios London Dec 20, 1967 "Top Gear"
Disc 2 Tracks 1-4: 201 Piccadilly Studio 1 London June 25 1968 "Top Gear"
Disc 2 Track 5: London Nov 3, 1968 BBC TV "All My Loving"
Disc 2 Tracks 6-9: Maida Vale Studios London Dec 2, 1968 "Top Gear"
Disc 2 Tracks: 10-14: Paris Cinema London May 12, 1969 "Top Gear"
Disc 3 Tracks 1,2: BBC Television Centre London Jul 10, 1969 "Omnibus"
Disc 3 Tracks 3-7: Paris Cinema London Jul 16, 1970 "Peel Sunday Concert"
Disc 4: Paris Cinema London Sep 30, 1971 "In Concert"
Piper Outtakes
Unknown
Unknown
Vegetable Man Where Are You?
Silas Land
Sunshine
In The Beechwoods
Atom Heart Mother, The High Resolution Remasters
Various
Various
Atom Heart Mother The Direct Discreet 4 Channel Tape Mixes / All Tracks Newly Remastered
Atom Heart Mother (Rear Channel) (23:40)
If (4 Channel) (4:29)
If (Front Channel) (4:28)
If (Rear Channel) (4:30)
Summer'68 (Front Channel) (5:32)
Fat Old Sun (Front Channel) (5:30)
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast (Front Channel) (12:02)
Atom Heart Mother High Resolution Remaster & Bonus Material / All Tracks Newly Remastered
Atom Heart Mother (23:43)
If (4:31)
Summer'68 (5:32)
Fat Old Sun (5:26)
Alan's Psychadelic Breakfast (13:05)
The Amazing Pudding (Live In Santa Barbara Monica 01/05/1970) (21:52)
Atom Heart Mother In Concert Part One
Atom Heart Mother (Live In Montreux 21/11/1970) (17:19)
If (Live At The Playhouse Theater 16/09/1970) (4:27)
Fat Old Sun (Live In Montreux 21/11/1970) (13:20)
Atom Heart Mother (Live In Santa Monica 23/10/1970) (29:13)
Fat Old Sun (Live In Santa Monica 23/10/1970) (13:00)
Atom Heart Mother In Concert Part Two
Atom Heart Mother (Live In Sheffield 22/12/1970) (33:19)
Atom Heart Mother (Encore) (Live In Shefield 22/12/1970) (2:56)
Fat Old Sun (Live In Shefield 22/12/1970) (15:18)
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast (Live In Shefield 22/12/1970) (25:14)
Lim. Edition of 300 numbered copies
Incl. a 12 page booklet with the complete tracklistings and information
Meddle - High Resolution Remaster
Various
Various
Meddle - Outtakes & Rarities:
Meddle (Radio Advertisment)
One Of These Days (Demo - Longer Version)
One Of These Days (Demo - Shorter Version)
One Of These Days (Mono Edit Version)
One Of These Days (Roland Petit Version 1)
One Of These Days (Roland Petit Version 2)
Fearless (Mono Edit Version)
Echoes (Quad Mix 2016
Echoes (Edited Version 2001)
Echoes (Interviews & Recording Session)
Meddle - High Resolution Remaster & Bonus Material:
One Of These Days
A Pillow Of Winds
Fearless
San Tropez
Echoes
One Of These Days / Echoes (Roland Petit TV)
Meddle - In Concert Part One:
One Of These Days (Cleveland 1971)
One Of These Days (Hollywood Bowl 1972)
One Of These Days (Earls Court)
Return of The Son Of Nothing (Berlin 1971)
Echoes (Boston 1975)
Meddle - In Concert Part Two:
Echoes (Cleveland 1971)
Echoes (Hollywood Bowl 1972)
Echoes (Earls Court 1973)
Lim. Edition of 300 numbered copies
Incl. a 12 page booklet with the complete tracklistings and information
Omayyad
Various
Various
Oenone (Studio)
Fingal's Cave (Studio)
Interstellar Overdrive (Live)
Crumbeling Land (Original Long Studio Version)
Rain In The Country (Studio)
The Embryo (Live)
Studio outtakes from the film Zabriskie Point recording sessions, December 1969.
Live tracks from the Santa Monica Civic Auditorium, California, 1970-05-01. Live tracks have long been attributed to the Chicago 1971-10-27 show until a complete recording of that performance became available (Echoes in the Auditorium, Hip Cat Records).
Umma & Gumma
Various
Various
~~~UMMA~~~ Studio
Sysyphus Part 1
Sysyphus Part 2 / The Violent Sequence (aka The Riot Scene, early Us & Them - from The Ultimate Zabriskie Point)
Sysyphus Part 3 (pitched down half a step) Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave (backwards)
Sysyphus Part 4 (1st half) / Grooving With A Pict (vocals only)
Sysyphus Part 4 (2nd half = part 1 reprise)
Oenone (from The Ultimate Zabriskie Point) / Selene (aka Moonhead aka Corrosion - BBC TV 7/69 documentary on the moonlanding)
Dythyramb from Grantchester Meadows (ripped from KQED DVD soundtrack 71_04_28)
Careful with that sickle, Cronus
(aka Come In #51, Your Turn Is Up - film version for intro and end + soundtrack version for middle section - from The Ultimate Zabriskie Point)
The Narrow Way, Part 1 (unknown song - soundtrack version - from The Ultimate Zabriskie Point)
The Narrow Way, Part 2
The Narrow Way, Part 3 (69-05-12 Paris Cinema London - from BBC archives)
The Embryo (from Works)
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party: Entrance
Heart Beat, Pig Meat (from The Ultimate Zabriskie Point)
Nick's Boogie (London 66-67) / The Grand Vizier's Garden Party: Entertainment
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party: Exit
Biding My Time (from Relics)
~~~GUMMA~~~ Live
Grantchester Meadows
Recorded live at the Fillmore West, San Francisco, USA on 70-04-29
Astronomy Dominé
Recorded live at the Fillmore West, San Francisco, USA on 70-04-29
Impro on Interstellar Overdrive and Moonhead
Recorded live at Ernst-Merck Halle, Hamburg, West-Germany on 70-11-14
Grooving With A Pict
Recorded live at Ernst-Merck Halle, Hamburg, West-Germany on 70-11-14
The Embryo + Roger Introducing The Massed Gadgets of Auximenes
Recorded live at Ernst-Merck Halle, Hamburg, West-Germany on 70-11-14
Careful With That Axe, Eugene
Recorded live at the Hallenstadion, Zurich, Switserland on 72-12-09
Sysyphus
Recorded live at the Town Hall, Birmingham, England on 70-02-11
The Narrow Way Part 1 aka Baby Blue Shuffle In D Major
Recorded in the BBC Maida Vale Studios on 68-12-02
The Narrow Way Part 3
Recorded live at the Royal Festival Hall, London, England on 69-04-14
The Pink Jungle / intro of The Labyrinth of Auximenes
Recorded live at the Royal Festival Hall, London, England on 69-04-14
Heart Beat, Pig Meat
Recorded live at the Town Hall, Birmingham, England on 70-02-11
Piano Impro
Recorded live at te Fairfield Hall, Croydon, England on 70-01-18
The Violent Sequence
Recorded live at the Theâtre des Champs-Elysées, Paris, France on 70-01-23
Biding My Time
Recorded live at the Concertgebouw, Amsterdam, The Netherlands on 69-09-21
Doing It
Recorded live at the Concertgebouw, Amsterdam, The Netherlands on 69-09-21
Recorded live at the Royal Festival Hall, London, England on 69-04-14
Encores:
Green Is The Colour
Recorded live at the University of Southampton, Southampton, UK on 69-05-09
Beset By Creatures of The Deep
Recorded live at the University of Southampton, Southampton, UK on 69-05-09
Biding My Time (reprise) aka Just another 12-bar
Recorded live at the Altes Casino, Montreux, Switserland on 70-11-22
1. WHAT IS IT?
Revisiting UMMAGUMMA as if it was a band-album, including left-overs and alternate versions, plus some home-made edits. Giving it a brandnew concept. (So this could have been PF's first concept album!)
2. WHY?
The idea for this project came in mind when I considered it was a pity that "The Embryo" and "Biding my Time" were recorded for Ummagumma but left out in spite of the concept of making it a 'four-men-solo album'. My first thought was then to burn a copy of Ummagumma for myself, just including those songs at the end of the album. But then I thought: "Why not making it an extended alternate version?" Inspiration also came from Muabdib's studio remix of "The Man & The Journey" (which I recommand!) and the enhanced Wall version "Every Brick In The Wall".
It's obvious that the original concept of Ummagumma didn't work out like the band wished it to. Quotes from the band members are clear on this subject:
"We all believed it was going to be one of the best things we'd ever put onto record, which I think it was at that time, but the stuff on the album isn't half as good as we can play." -Rick
"For me, it was just an experiment. I think it was badly recorded, the studio side could have been done better. We're thinking of doing it again." -David
"This was absolutely not a band album. The live stuff sounds incredibly antiquated now [...]. We were looking for new ways of constructing an album, although I think what this demonstrates is that our sum is always better than the parts." -Nick
3. WHAT HAS BEEN DONE?
Well, I took the liberty to get rid of that solo-concept, and tried to mix what Ummagumma might have been if it was a real teamwork, giving it a different concept. I don't pretend I improved it, but I wished to include left-outs, unreleased material (principally from ZP, but which fits perfectly in the spirit of Ummagumma) and alternate versions. I had plenty of material (of different quality) to choose from, for 1969 was probably their most prolific year. Therefore I used as far as possible the best sources for those alternate versions, but except for the Zabriskie Point outtakes, quality failed in most of the cases. It's a pity even the audio rip of Grantchester Meadows from the Harvested's KQED DVD is only 19OKbps, hissy and had an annoying hum in the beginning. Other sources had less hiss but much more microphone noise! I tried the best I could to erase this hum and de-hiss it a bit withoput denaturating the audio spectrum with Noise Reduction.
Another thing I permitted myself is to rename some tracks in order to give it the mythological concept I conceived for the occasion. I took inspiration by the example of Sysyphus and Oenone and gave Greek mythological references to the whole album, hence Cronus instead of Eugene, Selene (goddess of the moon) for Moonhead, and a Grand Vizier's Garden party which became an authentic Roman orgie! I recommend you to read the liner notes while listening, for I tried to make it more or less conceptual with a storyline. In contrary, I left the original titles for the live set.
The choice of including 'Careful...' is less obvious, since this is a 68 song. But, I found it a shame that only the single version was available on official sources, and no version of this tune appears on the regular albums. This december 69 take of Careful for the ZP soundtrack is radically different and much closer to what we use to hear on live roio's. The sound effects aer from the film itself, only the stereo effects for the footsteps and the riding car are mine. Other things that could be considered as 'sins' to some purists: I messed a lot with Sysyphus, integrating 'The Riot Scene' from ZP (aka The Violent Sequence, early Us & Them), 'Several Species...' backwards and the Pict rant without animal noises in it. Hence 'Several Species..' has
disappeared from the tracklist! But figure out in case of teamwork, Roger would maybe have done the same. Moreover you can clearly hear Roger rant more or less in the same part on the live version of Sysyphus (a fact I discovered AFTER mixing the studio album!!!)
The same 'dammages' occured to Nick's piece.
Figure out Syd came to help him get this piece a little more attractive!
4. WHAT ABOUT THE LIVE SET?
The live set isn't a gathering of alternate takes of what was originally on the live set of Ummagumma, but more what it would have sounded like if the band had once played (my) Ummagumma live. So here is a REAL live Ummagumma album, assembled from the most "mythic"
shows from 69-70 where the Floyd performed their strangest bits with an incredible energy. Especially on that night in Hamburg 70-11-14, Roger was in an incredibly talkative/rantic mood! Notice that powerful 'Embryo' including some jungle noises à la 'Several Species...' and 'Pow R. Toc H.' Alas and again, the shows featuring the rarest tracks like 'Moonhead' or 'Sysyphus' were badly recorded, and most sources are hissy, muffed, etc. The huge quality difference between the different sources I used, forced me
to use fades between some tracks, which I don't like but was the only way to make it sound acceptable. The SQ skips are more particulary noticeable in the 'meddley' I made.
A special note about 'The Narrow Way Part 3' though. The best recording is the one from the Amsterdam venue of 'The Man & The Journey'
. Musically, however, Dave's vocals are probably the worst he ever did in his whole life! His voice fails on all live performance of 'The Narrow Way'. That's why I choose this recording from the London premiere of 'The Man & The Journey': it's not the best source, but at least the vocals are barely audible, which is not a real loss in this case! :-)
CONCLUSION
I still hope you'll enjoy listening as I enjoyed mixing and compiling this.
Antiques and Curios
Various
Various
Green is the Colour
Careful With That Pipe Wrench, Larry
Main Theme from 'More'
Moonhead
The Pict Rant
Home Again
Mortality
Have a Cigar
Pigs on the Wing pt.2
The Last Few Bricks pt.2
The Last Few Bricks pt.2
Celestial Voices
Brain Damage/Lunar Eclipse
A Bonus Mystery Track...
1) Green is the Colour [3:20]
2) Careful With That Pipe Wrench, Larry [3:19]
from BBC Night Ride, May, 12, 1969
Ok, now what the hell is this doing on a "rareties" disc? Well, these tracks are often missing and/or replaced with the 1970 versions on many a RoIO, even some of the 'definitive' BBC collections These tracks are almost as rare as the 1970 'Fat Old Sun' broadcast found on Harvested's 'Mooed Music'. These have the bird sounds, and 'careful' isn't quite a normal version (ergo, my not-so-normal title). I would be interested to know if anyone has these tracks in pristine quality, as these are not ideal. [VG]
source:
'In Memoriam 1967-1981' Vinyl LP Box Set, colored vinyl.
3) Main Theme from 'More' [10:25]
Town Hall, Birmingham, Feb. 11, 1970
It's a cryin' shame this wasn't played "more" often. some digital tinkering happened here to squeeze what could be squeezed out of this. I think it sounds better than the ususal versions, but it's still not great. The performance, however, is incredible. This infact may be nick mason's finest moment. flamboyant, yet always tasteful. [VG]
source:
'In Memoriam 1967-1981' Vinyl LP Box Set, colored vinyl.
4) Moonhead [7:39]
5) The Pict Rant [3:50]
Ernst-Merke Halle, Hamburg, Nov. 14, 1970
A rare complete performance of Moonhead (aka 'Corrosion'), followed by one of Roger's best and most, um, vigorous, 'Pict Rants'. This comes from a clone of the master tape, and sounds better than the 'Grooving With a Pict' RoIO of this show. [EX-]
source:
Hamburg 1970 (DFA-013) CD-R
6) Home Again [1:45]
7) Mortality [3:30]
The Dome, Brighton, Jan. 20, 1972
The only instrumental performance of 'Home Again' (aka 'Breathe reprise') along with the 'preacher tape' organ noodling. Dave shows off with the voxbox guitar thing. I like this version quite a bit. Mortality ends about a minute earlier than on the source tape, because a loud and noise kicks in, as their PA system started to fail. An editorial decision was made to remove this unpleasantness from this release. It's just a bit more of the same organ fluff and sound effects, so it's not like there is anything 'important' compromised. [EX]
source:
The Darkside Rehearsals CD
8) Have a Cigar [5:07]
Knebworth Festival, UK, July 5, 1975
The last show of the 1975 tour, and the only live version with Roy Harper. After hearing this, you'll be grateful there's only one. Sound quality is not so hot, and the performance, is, well, tired. I'm sorry this turkey is in here, but hey. [VG-]
source:
Knebworth Park (Digital Floyd Project) CD-R
9) Pigs on the Wing pt.2 [3:39]
Olympic Stadium, Montreal, July 6, 1977
Roger shares some love with the audience. Later in the show he had more to share. This comes from a better source than 'Azimuth Coordinator', and one might be inclined to speculate that this is but a taste of things to come. Indeed. Nice solo from Snowy White. [EX+]
source:
Fireworks Show in the Canadian Walls CD-R
10) The Last Few Bricks pt.2 [8:16]
LA Arena, Los Angeles, Feb. 7, 1980
I could write a book on this 'song', but i won't. This is the last piece of new music from the 4-man lineup, the extra jam played on the first night of the Wall tour. It's a variation on an instrumental version of breathe (hmm, sound familiar?), was probably 'written' by dave gilmour, as he was the 'music director' for the shows, and i'll bet it was rehearsed once or twice. Often assumed to be a one-time improv jam to cover a lag in the stage show, it was infact played TWICE... [EX]
source:
Azimuth Coordinator vol3 CD
11) The Last Few Bricks pt.2 [3:16]
LA Arena, Los Angeles, Feb. 8, 1980
...and this is the other performance. It's a different arrangement, and about half as long as the night before. A true gem; performance-wise, I like this one better. but the sound quality is not as nice as the other. I didn't do the vinyl 'remastering' on this one, and there is too much noise reduction for my taste. [VG]
source:
A Little Black Book With my Poems In CD-R remastered from LP
12) Celestial Voices [9:13]
Royal Albert Hall, June 26, 1969
The only live performance of this with a choir and orchestra. 9 minutes long, this whopper originates from a better source than what usually circulates of this show. [VG]
source:
Pink Floyd in Concert with the Azimuth Co-Ordinator CD-R
13) Brain Damage/Lunar Eclipse (RoIO Remix 2000) [5:30]
Studio and Guild Hall, Portsmouth Jan 21, 1972
How's THAT for a tacky title? This is a combination of three oddities: The quadraphonic mixdown of Brain Damage from "Works", the guitar solos shown in the studio excepts of the Live at Pompeii movie, and the first performance of "Eclipse" (the song) at Portsmouth. Except, that it ain't quite a song yet, as you will hear. My edits are basically passable, but this is in NO WAY to be considered a rare studio outtake. I (ME) made this, for your amusement only.
[Studio/EX-] sources:
Works Vinyl LP
Pompeii Soundtrack Vinyl LP (Edgar Rubabande)
Eclipse of the Dark Side a Piece for Assorted Lunatics CD
14) A Bonus Mystery Track... [EX+]
BBC Mono Masters
London
UK
Paris Theatre, Lower Regent St, London, England
16 July 1970
Embryo
Fat Old Sun
Green is the Colour-
Careful with that Axe Eugene
If
Atom Heart Mother
Paris Theatre, Lower Regent St, London, England
30 September 1971
Fat Old Sun
One of These Days
Embryo
Echoes
BBC Studios, Picadilly, London, England
25 June 1968
The Murderotic Woman or Careful with that Axe Eugene
The Massed Gadgets of Hercules
Let there be more Light
Julia Dream
In 1998 a recording of Hendrix at Clark University in 1968 was found in the BBC archives after research by an employee at the National Sound Archives in London. This recording was subsequently released by Experience Hendrix on their dagger label. Shortly after the Hendrix had surfaced I asked the contact at the NSA if he had access to any Pink Floyd recordings. He was able to book out and copy the 1970 and 1971 shows to DAT. He later found the complete broadcast of the 1968 Top Gear show which was also transferred to DAT. At that time CDR was still a relatively new format and I sent the two concert DATs to a friend in the States to copy to CDR. The CDRS made it safely back across the Atlantic but the DATs, which had been sent separately, went missing somewhere in transit.
There is nothing new here, all that is new is a fresh transfer from the original CDRs and in the case of the 1968 broadcast, the DAT. This package brings these three mono masters together for the first time. Artwork included.
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Interstellar Overdrive - BBC 12/68
One Of These Days version 1 - unknown
One Of These Days version 2 - unknown
Pink Floyd German Trading Tape at 24/96
French TV Broadcasts 1968-1971
various
various
Astronomy Domine (20Feb68)
Flaming (20Feb68)
Let There Be More Light (20Feb68)
Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun (20Feb68)
Let There Be More Light (07Sep68)
Flaming (31Oct68)
Let There Be More Light (31Oct68)
Corrosion (04-05Dec70)
Cymbaline (15Jun71)
Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun (15Jun71)
All tracks sourced from French TV archives (pre-broadcast),
except track 5 sourced from Jan10 rebroadcast on Melody TV.
Tracks 1 to 4:
recorded in Paris, Buttes Chaumont, ORTF studios, 20Feb68
broadcast on "Bouton Rouge" TV show, 24Feb68
Track 5:
recorded in Paris, Le Bilboquet, 07Sep68
broadcast on "Surprise Partie" TV show, 31Dec68
Tracks 6 and 7:
recorded in Paris, Chapiteau du Kremlin-Bicetre, 31Oct68
broadcast on "Tous En Scene" TV show, 26Nov68
Track 8:
recorded in Paris, Buttes Chaumont, ORTF studios, 04-05Dec70
broadcast on "Speciale Roland Petit" TV show, 02Jan71
Tracks 9 and 10:
recorded in Royaumont, Abbaye de Royaumont, 15Jun71
broadcast on "Cinq Grand Sur La Deux" TV show, 12Jul71
Also released as "This Place Records TPR CD 007"